Key Takeaways
- Strong headline growth, one-off boost: Consolidated revenue rose 43% YoY, while PAT and cash profit included an exceptional one-off insurance claim of ₹17.3 crore for prior-year fire damage.
- Core margin structure held stable: Management sees the business operating within a 14–15% EBITDA band, with deviations of 2–3% in better or worse years, and expects to continue along that trend.
- Volume engine is sputtering: The bread-and-butter mass consumption business has been slow for 4–5 months, with customer volume numbers sluggish as inflation bites, even while the premium portfolio grows off a small base.
- New ventures are early and unproven: Flexible Packaging utilization is ramping from a low base, the COPPL rigid-box acquisition is margin-dilutive until revenue scales, and Innofilms is navigating a long gestation of trials with only initial commercial supplies.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether pre-Diwali stocking translates into actual offtake or crashes post-festival, any sign that mass-consumption volumes are bottoming, and the pace of the Flexible Packaging utilization ramp.
Demand & Volume: The Mass-Market Slowdown
- Domestic volume softness: The last 4–5 months have been slow, with customer volume numbers sluggish due to the impact of inflation on mass consumption.
- Premium vs. mass divergence: The premium portfolio is growing but remains a very small part of overall volume; the bread-and-butter mass business is not growing, and management noted that "nobody's happy" when the core stalls even if premium ticks up.
- Bullwhip effect clouds the signal: Management cautioned it is very hard to read true consumer-end demand because the company sits at the far end of the supply chain, where customer stocking or destocking can mask or exaggerate real offtake.
- Seasonality risk: Pre-Diwali stocking is underway, but if that material does not move, offtake crashes in the subsequent months, creating a near-term binary outcome for volumes.
Akshay Kanoria: "When your bread-and-butter business is not growing, then obviously nobody's happy, even if the premium portfolio is still growing. But that's a very small part of overall volume."
Margin Structure & Profitability
- Stable band with cyclical swing: The company has operated in a range of about 14–15% EBITDA; on a better year it goes up 2–3%, on a worst year it goes down 2–3%, a structure management calls broadly stable.
- Raw material pass-through mechanics: A lag effect and pass-through mechanism with customers means declining raw material prices give a short-term, short-lived margin boost, while a benign raw material environment reduces customer pressure to renegotiate.
- Utilization is the margin lever: Management tied the margin outlook directly to utilization levels staying decent and investments being managed prudently, with no structural reason seen to deviate from the trend.
- Interest cost contained: Interest cost was only marginally affected by rate rises, and interest as a percentage of turnover has come down.
Akshay Kanoria: "So broadly, we are quite stable as a company in our margin structure, and we see ourselves continuing along that trend. And as long as the utilization levels stays decent, we manage our investment prudently, we don't see why we can't manage this sort of level of margins."
Flexible Packaging: The Slow Ramp
- Utilization still climbing from a low base: Utilization at the recently commissioned Silvasa line has picked up from below 50% after a capacity doubling, but remains far from 100%, while the legacy Paperboard packaging business has run at much higher utilization for the last three quarters.
- On track but no date: The company is progressively ramping up and stated it is on track to achieve optimal volumes over the next few quarters, but offered no specific timeline.
- Capacity review deferred: Management will review the case for further Flexible Packaging capacity only once utilization is higher, "maybe sometime next year."
- Export-friendly economics: Flexible Packaging carries higher per-kg value and more volume per container, making it more export-friendly than Paperboard, and the export trend is described as very positive.
New Ventures: COPPL, Innofilms & the Diversification Bet
- COPPL (Creative Offset) acquisition: Entered the high-potential rigid box segment serving electronics end-users; since acquisition, has onboarded well-known brands in smartphones, smartwatches and headphones.
- COPPL margin drag today, promise tomorrow: Current margin is quite low because of low sales revenue and utilization; management sees it as a higher-margin business than the existing portfolio once the top line scales, with a target to reach triple-digit revenue in coming years, though no date was guided.
- COPPL demand headwinds: Short-term supply issues including the chip shortage and China component shortages, plus inflation, have hurt electronics demand, but management sees a big structural shift underway.
- Innofilms: early and long-gestation: The wholly owned subsidiary making single-polymer recyclable film has onboarded a few customers and begun commercial supplies, but the process involves runnability trials (few months), stability and shelf-life studies (up to 6 months), and transit trials (couple of months). The trend is positive but it is very early days.
- Europe energy crisis as tailwind: Management sees the energy crisis in Europe as a major problem for European competitors going forward and believes Asia will benefit, with the company positioned to capitalize.
Saket Kanoria: "But certainly, Asia will benefit thanks to this situation."
Competitive Positioning & the Paperboard Debate
- Paperboard demand thesis intact: Long-term potential for paperboard packaging remains very positive; globally, paperboard consumption and demand is growing, driven by sustainability trends, and India's per capita consumption is completely insignificant compared to global averages.
- Liquor-company moves not a trend: On whether phasing out of cardboard packaging by some companies is a trend, management pushed back, arguing it is too early to call it one if only one or two companies have expressed sentiment, and noted that packaging is an integral part of the product.
- Savings math questioned: Management argued the saving from removing paperboard may not be significant because companies would have to invest in augmenting secondary packaging, bottles and labels, so the net benefit is unclear and the company is not unduly concerned.
- Already competing with scaled players: The company is already competing with Huhtamaki and UFlex, servicing the same customers in the Carton business; Innofilms provides a good technological basis to compete further, with cross-selling and share-of-wallet opportunities.
Akshay Kanoria: "However, what we find is that, the saving is not going to be very significant because ultimately the company will have to invest in augmenting the secondary packaging, the bottles, the labels, and those kinds of things. So, we're not really sure how much it will save them. So, with that in mind we're not unduly concerned I would say."
Capital Allocation & Balance Sheet
- Capex run rate: A budget of approximately ₹80 crore to ₹100 crore per year for the next three years is broadly okay, with enough space in existing plants for quick brownfield additions when utilization warrants.
- Folding Carton capacity add: A new machine adding roughly 5,000 tonnes, or about 8% to the overall base, is being added at one plant by the end of this year.
- Debt and return metrics improving: If capacity expansion remains moderate, ratios, interest burden and depreciation burden improve; debt-equity has improved over the last couple of years and will continue to do so. The company targets a 20%+ return on capital and is satisfied as long as that is maintained.
- Working capital elevated: The last two years saw significant volatility in raw material pricing and availability, leading to increased working capital requirements in terms of stock levels maintained.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Flexible Packaging utilization | Achieve optimal volumes at the recently commissioned Silvasa line | Over the next few quarters |
| COPPL revenue scale | Grow to triple-digit revenue, become a critical part of overall growth | No date given; "coming years" |
| Overall EBITDA margin | Continue along the 14–15% trend, with 2–3% deviation in better/worse years | Ongoing, conditional on decent utilization and prudent investment |
| Return on capital | Maintain 20%+ RoCE | Ongoing |
| Annual capex envelope | Approximately ₹80 cr–₹100 cr per year | Next three years |
| Folding Carton capacity addition | Add ~5,000 tonnes at one plant | By end of this year |
| Flexible Packaging capacity review | Review case for further capacity addition | Maybe sometime next year, once utilization is higher |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | ₹361.7 cr, up 43% YoY |
| EBITDA | ₹57.5 cr, up 60% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 16% |
| PBT | ₹32.7 cr, up 120% YoY |
| PAT | ₹39.5 cr |
| Cash profit | ₹65.8 cr |
| Exceptional income (insurance claim) | ₹17.3 cr, included in PAT and cash profit, pertains to prior-year fire loss |
| Paperboard share of turnover | ~90% |
| Flexible Packaging EBITDA margin | ~10% |
| Working capital requirement | ~60 days |
| Folding Carton capacity addition | ~5,000 tonnes, ~8% of overall capacity |
| Headroom on current run rate | 15%–20% more without major issues |
| Annual capex estimate (next 3 years) | ~₹80 cr–₹100 cr |
| RoCE target | 20%+ |