Key Takeaways
- Volume-led growth, price headwind: Revenue growth shifted from price-led in Q1 to volume-driven in Q2, with price declining as raw material costs fell. Exports and the flexible business carried the quarter while domestic stayed flat.
- Domestic demand losing steam: Festive season buoyancy, strong through August, has faded over the past month; management sees no decline but says the mood is not as buoyant as prior years.
- Margins defended on mix and cost: EBITDA margin held up through a better product mix and internal cost management, even as the faster-growing flexible business typically carries lower margins.
- CAPEX moderating, deleveraging ahead: Full-year CAPEX of ~₹110 crore is front-loaded in H1; management flagged moderate plans for the next one to two years and expects absolute debt to fall.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the festive demand softness deepens into a broader domestic slowdown, progress on Innofilms’ equipment fixes, and the pace of the Creative stake move to 100%.
Domestic Demand & Volume Dynamics
- Volume took over from price: Q1 growth was more price-led; Q2 saw price decline as raw material costs dropped, so the growth that remained was volume-driven.
- Domestic flat, exports up: The domestic segment was under pressure and did not grow beyond the 4%-5% industry rate, while exports and the flexible business drove overall growth.
- Liquor decartonization hit H1: The company bore the brunt of the liquor industry’s shift away from carton packaging, with the bulk of the impact concentrated in H1 versus the same period last year.
- Festive mood check: Festive demand was very buoyant through August, but over the past month that buoyancy has gone missing; there is no decline, just a less exuberant consumer.
Saket Kanoria: "I think that this festive till August was very buoyant, but over the past month or so, I feel that that usual buoyancy is kind of missing. And while there is obviously no decline or anything, it's not as buoyant as we have seen in the past years."
Export & Flexible Business
- Exports entered new geographies: Export growth came across many segments with no single driver; the company entered new countries including the U.S., where the opportunity spans both flexible and carton packaging.
- Flexibles outgrowing carton: The flexible business had good growth and is outgrowing the traditional carton segment; margins were maintained despite flexibles growing faster.
- U.S. play is dual-format: Growth in the U.S. market will happen in both flexible and carton segments, not just one.
Margins & Cost Structure
- Mix and cost management held margins: EBITDA margin was supported by a better product mix and proactive internal cost management; the cost improvements are structural, not one-time.
- Raw material prices moving in opposite directions: Certain virgin-grade paper prices are rising, while recycled grades are falling; overall, no major change in input costs is expected because the company passes costs through.
- Flexible margins intact: Even as the flexible business grows faster, margins in that segment have been maintained.
CAPEX, Debt & Capacity Expansion
- CAPEX front-loaded, then moderating: The full-year CAPEX plan is ~₹110 crore, with the bulk spent in H1; management described the next one to two years’ CAPEX plans as quite moderate, signaling more free cash flow ahead.
- Debt to decline: Absolute debt levels are expected to come down from current levels.
- Silvassa third line nearing completion: The third line at the Silvassa plant is expected to finish during the current quarter and hopefully enter production in Q4 of the next fiscal year.
- Haridwar line already optimal: A new advanced printing line with ancillary equipment was inaugurated at the Haridwar facility and is already operating at optimal levels.
Subsidiaries: Creative & Innofilms
- Creative stake moving to 100%: The stake in Creative increased during the quarter and is expected to become 100% very soon.
- Creative growth faster, margins later: Creative should grow at a faster rate than the company overall and over time represent a meaningful share of total revenue; bottom-line contribution will follow once the top line reaches a more respectable scale, as overheads currently absorb earnings.
- Innofilms equipment challenges persist: Technical challenges with equipment are being addressed with the machine and technology provider; partial solutions are delivering partial benefits, but full restoration is expected to take another few months.
Saket Kanoria: "So, in Innofilms, you probably are aware that we have some technical challenges with the equipments which we have taken up with our machine and technology provider. They have worked on some partial solutions which are giving some partial benefits, but we expect that another few months will take before everything is restored to what it should achieve."
Saket Kanoria: "So, here is also again problem of scale and overall size. So, we see that once we come to a more respectable top line number, then the bottom line will certainly follow. Right now, it's kind of getting eaten up in overheads."
Governance & Industry Recognition
- Board strengthened: Two new Independent Directors were appointed: Mr. Sanjiv Anand (Chairman, Cedar Consulting) and Mr. Tarang Jain (Chairman & MD, Varroc Engineering), following the earlier addition of Dr. Blaschke.
- Awards haul: TCPL was named PrintWeek Printing Company of the Year and Innovative Printer of the Year 2023; Creative Offset Printers earned Best Vendor for EHS Activities from Samsung India with a perfect score; the company secured six awards at the India Folding and Carton Association Awards 2023.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| CAPEX moderation | Full-year CAPEX ~₹110 crore, bulk done in H1; next one to two years’ plans quite moderate | FY24 and beyond |
| Absolute debt reduction | Absolute debt should come down from current levels | Unspecified |
| Silvassa third line | Third line to complete during current quarter, production in Q4 next year | Completion: current quarter; production: Q4 FY25 |
| Creative stake | Expected to become 100% very soon | Unspecified |
| Innofilms equipment restoration | Partial solutions giving partial benefits; full restoration expected in another few months | Few months |
| Creative growth trajectory | Should grow faster than company rate; meaningful revenue share over time; bottom line follows once top line reaches respectable scale | Over time |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹406 cr, +12% YoY, highest ever quarterly revenue |
| EBITDA | ₹65 cr, +13% YoY |
| EBITDA margin | ~16%, steady |
| PBT | ₹37 cr |
| PAT | ₹29 cr |
| Cash profit | ₹55 cr |
| Exceptional item (prior year) | ₹17 cr one-off insurance claim in Q2 FY23, adjusted for which profits grew in line with revenue |
| Full-year CAPEX plan | ~₹110 cr, bulk completed in H1 |
| Revenue mix: flexible packaging | ~15% of total revenue |
| Capacity utilization: folding carton | 75% to 80% (excludes Haridwar new line commissioned in September) |
| Capacity utilization: flexible packaging | 80% to 85% |
| Haridwar capacity addition | ~25% of existing Haridwar capacity, overall about 20% |
| Domestic industry growth | 4% to 5%, domestic revenue flat with growth driven by exports and flexible business |
| Raw material price pass-through lag | Typically one quarter |