Key Takeaways
- Revenue surged 43% in 9M FY23: Volume growth, better realizations, and a faster-than-expected flexible packaging ramp-up drove the expansion, with exports outpacing domestic growth.
- Flexible packaging hit 90% utilization within nine months: The second line, commissioned at the start of the year, reached high utilization only in Q3, triggering immediate plans for a third, lower-cost brownfield line.
- Gross margin dipped below 40% on a pass-through technicality: Raw material cost rose to 60-61% of sales, mechanically compressing the margin percentage even though the absolute cost is passed on; scale benefits in employee cost provided an offset.
- Creative Offset (COPPL) is a struggle that will take until FY25: The rigid-box venture is EBITDA breakeven but net negative, with scale building slower than anticipated in a new segment; management hopes it approaches parent-level margins only in FY25.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the new paperboard offset line commissions on time by end-March 2023, the pace of flexible packaging’s third-line decision, and any raw material price movement as China reopens.
Flexible Packaging: The New Growth Engine
- Utilization leap: The second line started in April but volume picked up meaningfully only in Q3, taking combined utilization across old and new lines to 90%, a level reached in just nine months that management calls the trigger for further expansion.
- Margin recovery underway: Flexible margins improved significantly in Q3 after being compressed earlier by overhead loading on a single line; further growth is expected as more premium offerings are introduced and output becomes more consistent.
- Structural margin ceiling: Flexible margins will not match paperboard carton margins because the turnover ratio in flexible is much higher, a basic industry structure management does not expect to change.
- Third line imminent: Management is considering a third brownfield line in the near future at comparatively lower capex since land, building and other costs were already incurred in the recent expansion; FY24 flexible packaging capex is pegged at ₹50 crore.
- Multi-plant future not ruled out: Immediate priority is to grow and optimize the current site, but multiple plants in the future are a possibility management is open to, with no immediate plans for new locations.
Saket Kanoria: "The capacity utilization of the flexible now, the old and the new plant, is at 90% levels. This is only since the last quarter. And it's operating at very high-level utilization, and in the short span of nine months. So, that's why we are very excited to look at the further expansion in this segment."
Exports: A Structural Tailwind
- Export share rising: Export growth this year has been slightly higher than domestic growth, so exports are claiming a higher share of overall revenue, supported by lower freight costs, a favorable exchange rate, raw material availability, and an improved image of India as a sourcing hub.
- China diversification driving visits: Multinational customers and parents are visiting and exploring India specifically to diversify out of China; management sees this as a broad export opportunity beyond any single sustainability angle.
- Middle East office established: A new office in the Middle East is supporting export efforts, and management is quite bullish, saying the export environment out of India currently has more positives than at any point in the last couple of years, at least since COVID.
- Capacity stance is opportunistic: Management reserves the right to add capacity any time an export opportunity arises and will not let an opportunity go for lack of capacity, but will not set up a plant and wait for exports to come.
Saket Kanoria: "We are quite bullish on the export market, because we have also established an office in the Middle East that is helping our efforts. And in generally, the mood on India is very positive. The exchange rate is also in our favor. The freight costs have come down. So, overall, export out of India currently has more positive than it's ever been, you know, last couple of years, at least since COVID."
Margins: The Pass-Through Math and the Volume Bet
- Gross margin dip is mechanical, not operational: Gross margin declined marginally to ~39.3% from a historical ~40-41% because raw material cost as a percentage of sales moved up from 57-58% to 60-61%; even though the absolute raw material cost is passed on to customers, no margin is earned on the pass-through increase, so the ratio compresses.
- Scale offset from employee cost: Employee cost declined as a percentage of sales because of scale benefits, which helped offset the raw material percentage increase and maintain similar gross margin levels.
- Volume growth is the margin lever: Management would be happy to maintain similar EBITDA levels on a higher base going forward, but acknowledges that at 2-3% country-wide FMCG volume growth, it is very challenging to grow margins; a more buoyant volume environment would lift all boats.
- Raw material stability expected: Paperboard segment prices are currently stable; China recently opened up creating some demand factors, but no major change is expected, and the revenue run rate does not face a sharp correction because raw material price declines have been gradual and already factored in.
Saket Kanoria: "If we are talking of 2%, 3% volume growth as a FMCG sale, then it is very challenging to grow margin. But yes, if the volume growth as a country as a whole becomes more buoyant, then, I think, you know, rising tide will lift all boats."
Creative Offset (COPPL): The Long Slog
- Below breakeven, scale elusive: COPPL is at EBITDA breakeven but net negative; scale is still very small and the ramp is taking longer than anticipated because it is a new business in a new segment.
- Stake increased to 84%: TCPL invested in COPPL's recent rights issue, raising its stake, and several customers have been onboarded in the rigid box segment for the smartphone industry.
- FY25 profitability target: Management hopes COPPL will come to a position very close to the parent company in FY25, but acknowledges it is a struggle; the overall industry is expected to keep growing for the next four to five years driven by PLI schemes.
- Revenue doubling as a floor: Management hopes to double COPPL revenue in a couple of years as a bare minimum, with upside dependent on segment performance and electronics demand-supply dynamics.
Saket Kanoria: "Really speaking, I would think that in the year 2024-25 is when we hope to come to a position very close to the parent Company. But it's a struggle. It's a new business, new segment. And therefore, it is taking a little longer than anticipated."
Capacity & Capex
- Paperboard offset line on track: A new line of 5,000 tons is expected to be commissioned by end of March 2023, and debottlenecking capex on the paperboard side is expected to be ready in Q4, adding 5-10% capacity.
- FY24 capex to moderate: FY24 capex is expected to be lower than FY23's ~₹100 crore, but management is looking at opportunities for additional investment and reserves the right to add paperboard capacity any time if an opportunity arises.
- Full-year revenue crossing ₹1,350 crore: Management expects the full-year turnover to cross this threshold, with consistent year-on-year growth expected to continue for the next two years, subject to the economy remaining in good shape.
- Volume growth to improve in FY24: Volume growth should be much better than FY23 because Indian inflation is now well within control and prices are being corrected; even if pricing corrects somewhat, volume increases from newly added capacity can overcome that.
- Sustainability initiatives underway: TCPL is working with customers to replace plastic food trays with biodegradable alternatives and reducing use of metalized plastic film by transferring metallized effects into paperboard; the subsidiary TCPL Innofilms has started producing eco-friendly PE blown films commercially.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Paperboard offset line commissioning | New 5,000-ton line operational | End of March 2023 |
| Debottlenecking capex completion | 5-10% paperboard capacity addition | Q4 FY23 (this quarter) |
| Full-year turnover | Cross ₹1,350 crore | FY23 |
| COPPL profitability | Reach a position very close to the parent company | FY25 |
| COPPL revenue doubling | Double revenue as a bare minimum | Within a couple of years |
| FY24 flexible packaging capex | ₹50 crore | FY24 |
| FY24 total capex | Lower than FY23's ~₹100 crore, subject to additional opportunities | FY24 |
| Volume growth improvement | Much better than FY23, driven by inflation control and price correction | FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue (net sales) | ₹358 cr, Q3 standalone; 9M FY23 total revenue ₹1,082 cr, +43% YoY |
| Expected FY23 turnover | ~₹1,350 cr, management confirmed "should certainly cross" this level |
| EBITDA margin (9M FY23) | 16%, 9M EBITDA ₹172 cr |
| Profit Before Tax (9M FY23) | ₹99 cr, +121% YoY |
| PAT (9M FY23) | ₹86 cr, +184% YoY |
| Cash profit (9M FY23) | ₹163 cr, +90% YoY |
| Gross margin | 39.2–39.3%, vs historical ~40–41%; raw material cost moved to 60–61% of revenue |
| Flexible packaging capacity utilization | 90% (cumulative, old and new plant combined) in Q3 |
| Paperboard carton capacity utilization | ~80% overall |
| Export share (FY22) | ~25% of overall revenue; export growth in FY23 slightly higher than domestic growth |
| Creative Offset Printers quarterly run rate | ₹12–13 cr |
| Stake in Creative Offset Printers | 84%, increased via rights issue |
| FY23 capex | ~₹100 cr |
| FY24 capex (flexible packaging third line) | ₹50 cr, Brownfield; turnover ratio expected >2.5x |
| Paperboard debottlenecking capacity addition | 5–10%, expected online in Q4 FY23 |