Key Takeaways
- Volume growth decoupled from end-markets: FY22 revenue grew ~18% while volume grew just under 5%, driven by share gains in existing customers and new customer development, even as FMCG volume growth stayed weak industry-wide.
- Flexible packaging capacity doubled: A second line at Silvassa was commissioned in late March, effectively doubling segment capacity; only a few days of contribution landed in Q4, so the full ramp is a FY23 story.
- Creative acquisition is a near-term drag: Consolidated from December 2021, Creative is currently PAT-negative and accounts for the bulk of the dip between standalone and consolidated results; management expects a turnaround "in a few months."
- Margins held but the cost environment is unforgiving: Gross margin year-to-date was ~39–40%, close to the 42–43% historical level, though management called the incremental cost to maintain that kind of incremental margin "very challenging" given high inflation.
- What to watch next quarter: The pace of utilization ramp on the new flexible packaging line, the trajectory of Creative's losses, and whether recycled paper price softness translates into margin relief.
Volume & Revenue Dynamics
- Realization-led revenue growth: FY22 revenue grew ~18% on volume growth of just under 5%, implying significant realization growth driven by raw material price pass-through; Q4 showed a similar or higher pattern.
- Share gains drove volumes: TCPL grew volumes ~4–5% by increasing share of business in existing customers and developing new customers, despite weak FMCG volume growth industry-wide.
- Base carton growth ambition: Management stated that a 10–15% growth rate in the base carton packaging business is "more than possible" and has been achieved beyond that in recent years.
- Export mix steady at ~23%: Exports were ~23% of revenue for FY22, spread across Europe (Netherlands, Sweden, UK), the Middle East, and parts of Africa; management declined to provide quarter-on-quarter export proportions.
Akshay Kanoria: "there is a sort of secular shift towards paper, which has seen a sustained increase and I think that, plus lack of investment in these European and North American mills over many years has resulted in a big gap between demand and supply as far as paper is concerned."
Flexible Packaging Ramp
- Second line doubles capacity: The new line at Silvassa, including a 10-color gravure printing press and ancillary equipment, was commissioned successfully and effectively doubles segment capacity.
- Minimal Q4 contribution: The line was capitalized only at end of March, so only a few days of contribution landed in Q4; management expects to optimally utilize it over the next 12 months.
- Backward integration underway: TCPL Innofilms Private Limited, a wholly owned subsidiary, commenced trial production at its new film line at Silvassa, adding a captive film supply capability.
- Gross margin structurally lower: Flexible business gross margin is lower than the traditional carton business, so mix shift toward flexible will weigh on blended margins even as it adds absolute profit.
Creative Acquisition: Near-Term Pain, Long-Term Bet
- PAT-negative and the main consolidation drag: Creative was consolidated from 4 December 2021 and is currently PAT-negative; the dip between standalone and consolidated results is majorly the loss from Creative.
- Turnaround expected "in a few months": Management believes Creative can be turned around as benefits of scale, cost optimization, and synergies start contributing; post-acquisition investment is underway to modernize the facility and optimize processes.
- Long-term thesis intact but disrupted: Volume shifting to India and India volume growing is "very much baked in," but the immediate ramp-up is taking time due to disruptions: COVID, China zero-COVID, the war, and raw material scarcity.
- Expansion beyond mobile phones planned: Creative will also get into other forms of rigid box beyond mobile phones; the building is already being expanded with very modern equipment added, and management sees it as "a small unit" that "has to come to a much bigger scale."
Akshay Kanoria: "In the long-term volume shifting to India and the India volume growing that is very much baked in and we expect big improvement, but in the immediate time that is taking time because of all of these disruptions from COVID, China zero COVID and then this war situation and the RM scarcity and all of that."
Raw Material & Margin Outlook
- Diverging input cost trends: Recycled paper pricing was very high in Q4 but has since become soft and is going down; virgin board remains in short supply with costs still growing; in Flexible Packaging, solvents and chemicals are still inflationary but basic films are currently soft.
- Gross margin close to historical levels: Gross margin year-to-date was ~39–40%, close to the 42–43% historical level, though management called the incremental cost to maintain that kind of incremental margin "very challenging" given high inflation.
- Pricing has become more dynamic: Management noted that pricing is now far more dynamic and is regularly monitored by customers, implying faster pass-through mechanisms than in the past.
- Medium-term margin confidence: On sustainability of 14–15% margins over the medium term, management stated "we have achieved that. So, we don't see any reason why not."
Saket Kanoria: "I think no one is overlooking pricing at any time. As you said, it's a competitive business. But at the end of the day, you should get the material also on time now. That is the reliability and is very critical."
Capital Allocation & Returns
- ROCE recovering toward target: ROCE hit 20%+ about 7–8 years ago, then dipped to 10–13%, and is now improving to almost 15% this year due to better utilization and more efficiency; management's strategy is to manage 20%+ ROCE on investments and "we see that coming back."
- FY23 capex of INR 100 crore: Total outlay includes balance from last year plus a new offset carton line; expected asset turn is minimum 1.5–2x, likely higher.
- Dividend at a record high: Board recommended a dividend of INR 10 per share, the 22nd continuous year and the highest ever.
- Export expansion ambition: Management is looking to expand further to North America, where they see a lot of opportunity.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Flexible packaging ramp | Optimally utilize the new Silvassa line | Next 12 months |
| Creative turnaround | Turn PAT-positive via scale, cost optimization, and synergies | "In a few months" |
| ROCE recovery | Manage 20%+ ROCE on investments | No date; improving in recent months |
| Base carton growth | 10–15% growth rate sustained | Ongoing; "more than possible" |
| Capex asset turn | Minimum 1.5–2x on INR 100 crore FY23 outlay | FY23 and beyond |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated total revenue (FY22) | ₹1,088 cr, not comparable YoY due to Creative acquisition from Dec 2021 |
| Standalone PAT (FY22) | ₹49 cr |
| Standalone cash profits (FY22) | ₹125 cr |
| Consolidated PAT (FY22) | ₹47 cr |
| Revenue growth (FY22) | ~18% YoY, volume growth just under 5% |
| Volume growth (FY22) | Just under 5% YoY |
| Volume growth (Q4 FY22) | ~4% to 5% YoY, similar to full year, in fact higher |
| Gross margin (FY22 year-to-date) | ~39%, almost 40% roughly |
| ROCE (FY22) | ~15%, improved from 10% to 13% in prior years |
| Dividend per share | ₹10, highest ever, 22nd continuous year of payout |
| Export proportion of revenue (FY22) | ~23% |
| Virgin vs recycled paper mix | ~55% virgin, ~45% recycled |
| Creative revenue contribution (4 months since acquisition) | ₹9 cr (Q4 FY22) |
| Creative capacity utilization | ~40% |
| FY23 capex plan | ₹100 cr, for balance prior-year spend and new offset carton line |
| Debt | ~₹400 cr |