Key Takeaways
- Record profit, soft exit: FY23 PAT jumped 136% to Rs. 210 crore on 36% revenue growth, but Q4 demand turned surprisingly slow and that softness has continued into the new year.
- Subsidiaries are a drag, not yet a driver: Creative lost money at the net level despite 31% revenue growth; Innofilms lost Rs. 1.5 crore at EBITDA as a machine snag kept it running only for internal use. Both are promised turnarounds in FY24.
- Margin peak may be in: Paper prices are correcting, but management expects to pass the benefit to customers in a soft, competitive market and sees no margin expansion from the ~16% EBITDA level already achieved.
- Capacity bet placed into weak demand: A new offset line just started in Silvassa, a third flexible line and a Haridwar line are coming in H2 FY24, all justified by shorter customer run lengths and a readiness to carry lower utilization for a quarter or two.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether domestic volume growth actually returns as inflation eases, whether Innofilms’ technical snag is resolved in the promised 3–4 months, and whether Creative swings to profit.
Demand Environment
- Q4 surprise: Demand was quite slow over the last couple of months of FY23, with customers’ volume growth stuck in low single digits while value growth ran 10–15% purely on the prior year’s high inflation stretching consumer budgets.
- Inflation unwind: Management sees no reason volume growth should not return as inflationary pressures ease, but the last 2–3 months have not been strong at all and overall world demand remains under stress.
- Domestic volume reality: Household budgets were very constrained last year; volume growth was always 3–5%, never negative, but that low base is the starting point for any recovery.
- Export silver lining: Exports grew faster than the company average in FY23, partly fueled by inflation, and now represent about 25% of revenue. Double-digit export volume growth is seen as sustainable, with countries looking at India more seriously for outsourcing and currency providing a tailwind.
- The capacity paradox: Management added offset capacity not because demand is booming but because average customer run lengths are shrinking as brands proliferate. Running at very high utilization would hurt lead times, so the company is deliberately building headroom and is willing to tolerate lower utilization for a quarter or two.
Saket Kanoria: “It has been very surprising that the demand side is not very strong at all. Last couple of months it has been quite slow... the consumer budget has stretched. And now that the inflationary pressures are easing off hopefully volume growth should come back in a better way. There is no reason really for it not to come back.”
Subsidiary Health & Turnaround Promises
- Creative Packaging: First full year as a subsidiary coincided with a 6–7 month slump in mobile phone demand, its key end-market. Revenue grew 31% but the stabilization took longer than expected and the unit lost money at the net level, with EBITDA only near breakeven. Management is quite confident it will make money in FY24, citing a now broad-based customer profile.
- Innofilms: The technology itself has been the problem. A machine snag during the year required supplier part replacements, with one more part still on order. The line lost about Rs. 1.5 crore at EBITDA and is currently operating only for internal use. Customer acceptance is an ongoing effort, slowed by sustainable-packaging qualification requirements, shelf-life studies and filling-line adjustments.
- Innofilms timeline: Management expects another 2–3 months of struggle, then things should start turning around; the second half of FY24 should see proper operational levels. Interest in the product is described as great, with significant export opportunity, and the company remains very positive.
Margins & Pricing
- Record level achieved: FY23 EBITDA reached Rs. 236 crore at a ~16% margin, a record, driven by operational efficiency that mitigated raw material cost increases.
- Paper tailwind will be passed on: Paper prices have been correcting since January and are continuing to correct, but management was explicit that this benefit must be passed through to customers. In a competitive world with fairly soft overall demand, margin expansion from here is not expected; the endeavor is to maintain what has been achieved.
- Growth investment vs. margin: The company is adding capacity (new offset line, third flexible line, Haridwar line) and studying synergistic new areas, all while holding the view that margins have likely peaked for now.
Saket Kanoria: “The paper prices have started correcting since January... But once the paper price corrects, we also have to pass that through to customers. So, I do not see that the margin will expand from here, the margin is already quite healthy and we are also in a competitive world and overall demand is fairly soft.”
Capacity Expansion
- Silvassa offset line: A state-of-the-art Advanced Offset Printing line and associated equipment was commissioned and started commercial production, booked in April–May. Neighboring properties were acquired and integrated to accommodate the space requirement.
- Flexible packaging line three: A third line is being added at Silvassa, expected to start in the second half of FY24, which will effectively treble flexible capacity. Management is very confident of filling it fairly quickly, citing extremely pleasing performance from the capacity added in March–April 2022, with lots of new customers on board.
- Haridwar line: Another line is being installed at the Haridwar facility, also scheduled for the latter half of FY24. Old machines are being removed as part of the broader expansion and modernization program.
- Peak revenue from current base: From the Q4 run-rate, the company could do up another 10–12% without further capex, but hitting Rs. 1,800–2,000 crore is not practical without additional investment.
- Solar addition: Solar power capacity is also being added alongside the manufacturing lines.
Strategy & New Initiatives
- Synergistic adjacencies: Management is studying a couple of synergistic areas in the packaging space where the company is not present today, believing it should exploit whatever synergy potential exists. It is too early to discuss specifics.
- Board strengthening: Dr. Andreas Blaschke, with over three decades of global packaging experience and recently retired from Europe’s largest folding carton manufacturer, was added as an Independent Director. Vidur Kanoria was appointed Executive Director to reinforce business development and administration.
- Subsidiary merger: The Board decided to merge TCPL Innofilms into the parent company to eliminate redundant paperwork, streamline operations, optimize resources and improve productivity.
- Growth aspiration: Management pointed to a 17–18% average annualized growth rate as past performance and said it would be quite happy to achieve that going forward. The Rs. 2,000-odd crore top line is seen as achievable much quicker than five years.
Saket Kanoria: “Yes, we are studying a couple of synergistic areas where we are not there today, but it is too early to talk about it. But we are studying what the potential is because we believe that we should exploit whatever synergy potential there is in the packaging space.”
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Creative turnaround | Should make money and not lose money; broad-based customer profile developed | FY24 |
| Innofilms operational | Machine snag resolved, line at proper operational levels | H2 FY24 (struggle for another 2–3 months first) |
| Flexible capacity addition | Third line at Silvassa trebling flexible capacity, expected to start | H2 FY24 |
| Haridwar line | New line being installed | H2 FY24 |
| Margin outlook | Maintain achieved margin level; no expansion expected given competitive, soft-demand environment | Ongoing |
| Volume growth | Double-digit volume growth quite possible to continue; did it even last year | FY24 |
| Export volume growth | Double-digit volume growth on exports seen as sustainable | Ongoing |
| Revenue aspiration | 17–18% average annualized growth; Rs. 2,000-odd crore top line achievable much quicker than five years | Medium-term |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue (FY23) | ₹1,475 cr, +36% YoY |
| EBITDA (FY23) | ₹236 cr, margin of around 16% |
| PBT (FY23) | ₹132 cr, +98% YoY |
| PAT (FY23) | ₹210 cr, +136% YoY; includes exceptional one-off income of ₹17.3 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Cash profit (FY23) | ₹216 cr, +74% YoY |
| Dividend per share | ₹20, 23rd consecutive year of payout |
| ROCE (FY23) | 20% |
| ROE (FY23) | 28% |
| Capacity utilization (Q4) | ~75%, both in paper board and flexible packaging |
| Revenue growth ex-Creative (FY23) | ~30% topline, of which volume growth was ~12% |
| Export share of revenue | ~25% of revenue; export growth in FY23 was higher than overall Company growth |
| FY24 capex plan | Just above ₹100 cr cash spend; includes three new production lines and solar capacity |
| Carton capacity | ~100,000 tons currently; two new lines to add effective capacity of 14,000–15,000 tons |
| Flexible packaging capacity | ~10,000 tons base; adding ~6,000 tons in FY24 |
| Creative subsidiary revenue (FY23) | ₹32 cr, +31% YoY; EBITDA almost breakeven, net loss |
| Innofilms subsidiary EBITDA loss (FY23) | ~₹1.5 cr |