Key Takeaways
- Normalcy returns after two-year reset: FY24 revenue grew 5% as the twin headwinds of liquor de-cartoning and paper price deflation played out; management expects FY25 to be a normal year with a return to long-term growth trends.
- Margins hit a multi-year high: Q4 EBITDA margin reached 17.6%, the highest level, driven by benign raw material costs, improved job mix, and a positive contribution from subsidiaries, with no one-off or inventory gain.
- Innofilms is no longer a drag: After mechanical fixes and quality stabilization, the subsidiary has stopped being a drain on consolidated performance, though it is not yet a meaningful contributor.
- Greenfield expansion breaks a strategic bottleneck: A new Chennai plant, approved this quarter, addresses a long-term competitive threat from not having a physical presence in South India near key customers.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether domestic FMCG volume growth actually revives, the pace of export growth amid Red Sea disruptions, and any early signs of revenue contribution from the new Chennai facility.
Margin Recovery & Sustainability
- Q4 margin drivers: The 250 bps QoQ improvement came largely from raw material price changes and a better product mix showing up in raw material contribution; the subsidiary delta had a lesser role in this specific quarterly move.
- Raw material tailwind: Recycled board prices, which had doubled at their peak, remain a little above pre-COVID levels, while virgin board prices, which rose roughly 60-plus percent, have largely clawed back.
- Sustainable floor: Management views 15% to mid-teen EBITDA margin as a fairly sustainable number and sees the margin on an upward trajectory, sustaining at the 15-plus level.
- No one-off boost: The Q4 margin performance contained no inventory gain and no one-off item, reinforcing the view that the improvement is structural rather than episodic.
Subsidiary Turnaround
- Innofilms: Mechanical issues with the machine have been fixed and film quality is now more or less stabilized; the line is being used for regular films when not producing high-value-add film, keeping it productive.
- Creative: Several new customers have been cracked in electronics, consumer products, cosmetics and other segments; trial-order customers have converted to major orders starting this season, and growth is expected to continue in high double digits.
- Creative ambition: Management aims to turn Creative into a triple-digit crore revenue business focused on high-value, high-value-added products at the premium end; bottom line should become healthier once it reaches a certain revenue level.
- Subsidiary fragility: Revenue at the subsidiaries is still very small, so one bad month or one customer having a bad quarter can swing the whole performance; the focus is now on growing the level of operation, with confidence that the bottom line will follow.
Akshay Kanoria: "the drag has really kind of stopped becoming a drag this year. So it is no longer a drag. It's not adding anything much, but it's not a drag anymore."
Strategic Expansion: Chennai Greenfield
- The rationale: From a purely financial standpoint, brownfield expansion at existing units is more remunerative, but not having a presence in the deep South was becoming a long-term hindrance and a competitive threat to customer relationships and market standing.
- Location and scope: The board approved a new plant near Chennai on a long-term lease, close to major industrial hubs and a port; it starts with just one line and will take a while to really show up in the numbers.
- Timeline: Management hopes to start commissioning this calendar year, certainly this financial year, but the revenue impact is expected to start playing out only next financial year.
- Capex: Management declined to disclose capex for the individual plant.
Akshay Kanoria: "from a purely financial point of view, you should ideally keep growing the existing unit and keep doing brownfield because that's much more remunerated by definition. But from a business point of view, if you want to maintain your market standing and position and relationship with customer, relevance to customer, then you have to expand with your customers and to not be present in the deep South was becoming long-term sort of hindrance. Rather a bit of a threat, I'd say."
Demand Environment & End-Market Trends
- FMCG, the largest segment, has been flat: Volume growth over the last three years has been quite weak, marginal on a volume basis and flattish overall; management sees it hopefully coming back now.
- Liquor and paper headwinds have played out: The two major FY24 headwinds, liquor moving out of cartons and price reductions from 2023's high, have both run their course, setting the stage for a normal FY25.
- Export momentum, with a caveat: Exports have grown quite substantially over the last several years and management is very happy with performance and sees further room for growth, but the Red Sea crisis is a huge headache and a long-term deterrent for customers, pushing up shipping costs dramatically and making local suppliers more favourable.
- Red Sea margin pressure: Customers are not happy to take price increases and tend to force the company to bear some of the increased shipping cost, impacting both growth and margins.
- Rigid packaging opportunity: The market is very decentralized, dominated by small local players; management sees a long-term structural opportunity as premiumization continues and electronics and smartphone growth in India add to requirements, drawing a parallel to the paperboard packaging story of the 1990s and 2000s.
Akshay Kanoria: "So Pulkit, you asked me this question every year and last year also we kind of gave you a non-answer. So this year also, we will give you a non-answer only because we can't predict. Even if I wanted to predict, I don't know if I want to discuss in an earnings call."
Flexible & Sustainable Packaging
- Flexible capacity underutilized: A flexible line added mid-to-late last year still has low utilization; the company can do much bigger revenue on the flexible side, and no major capex is planned for flexible packaging for at least the next year.
- Sustainable mono-material line: The idea is to be a relevant player with a differentiated product; the addressable market is the entire flexible packaging industry, and the company needs only a few brands from its large customers to switch to generate enough volume.
- Competitive moat: Very few others in India and globally are doing this; it is a very complex product and a technical challenge to execute.
- Regulatory tailwind: The government is getting more focused on packaging with more stringent rules; Europe is going to have a tax on non-sustainable packaging, and India already has rules coming out about recycled content and recyclability of original packaging.
Akshay Kanoria: "The idea being that the overall market is so large that you don't really need everyone to switch to such kind of product, you just need a few brands really and there's enough volume that we can cater to for even 1 or 2 brands of our large customers."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | Return to long-term growth trend, contingent on domestic consumption revival | FY25 |
| EBITDA margin | Sustain at 15%-plus level on an upward trajectory | Ongoing |
| Chennai plant commissioning | Start operations | This calendar year, certainly this financial year |
| Chennai plant revenue contribution | Revenue impact to start playing out | Next financial year |
| Innofilms commercialization | Some innovative film applications to be commercialized | This financial year |
| Flexible packaging capex | No major capex planned | At least next year |
| Long-term revenue CAGR | Sustain approximately 17% CAGR | 30-year track record, ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Consolidated revenue | Crossed ₹400 cr, up 5% YoY to ₹1,541 cr for FY24 |
| EBITDA | ₹70 cr, margin of 17.6% |
| Cash PAT | ₹57 cr |
| FY24 EBITDA | ₹251 cr, up 7% YoY, margin of 16.3% |
| FY24 Cash PAT | ₹206 cr |
| Dividend per share | ₹22, 24th consecutive year of uninterrupted dividend payout |
| 30-year revenue CAGR | ~17% |
| FY25 capex budget | More than ₹100 cr, broadly in line with previous year |
| Overall capacity utilization | 75% to 80% |
| Flexible packaging capacity utilization | Lower than 60% to 70% |
| Export revenue share | 32% to 33% of revenues in FY24 |
| Net working capital days | 80 to 85 days for FY24 |
| QoQ EBITDA margin improvement | 250 bps, largely driven by RM price decline and product mix improvement |
| Paper packaging volume growth | Very low single digit for the quarter and full year |