Key Takeaways
- Subdued quarter, transient narrative: Revenue grew just 1.8% YoY as Western consumers shifted spend to experiences over products, but management calls the demand mix shift transient and points to sequential monthly improvement.
- Germany is the bright spot: Monthly revenue crossed €0.1 crore with gross margins ahead of the US and UK, and breakeven is now expected one year sooner than originally planned.
- Margins found a floor: EBITDA margin improved sequentially to 8.1% from 7.0% in Q1, and management expects continued H2 improvement toward the full-year 8–9% guided range.
- ASP spike masks volume weakness: Average selling price jumped to $35 as inflation drove consumers toward gold investment pieces; management calls this transient and expects a return to around $20 longer-term.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the sequential revenue improvement holds through the holiday season, the pace of Germany’s burn reduction, and any sign that US consumer sentiment is stabilizing.
Demand & Revenue Dynamics
- Top-line barely grew: Q2 FY23 sales of ₹646 crore rose 1.8% YoY, held back by Western consumers allocating more disposable income to experiences and travel after two years of COVID restrictions.
- US local currency declined: Shop LC US revenue fell 6.4% YoY on subdued demand and a very high base from the prior year.
- UK flattish on external shocks: Investment in Freeview channel upgrades drove new customer acquisition, but the Queen’s death and political changes produced a momentary drag that left UK growth roughly flat.
- TV volumes fell for two reasons: Consumers going out for holidays and vacations reduced viewing, while inflation and recession fears pushed buyers toward investment-perceived gold products (chains, rings, bracelets) that carry higher price points and lower unit volumes.
- ASP spike was a deliberate trade-off: Management chose to meet revenue numbers by leaning into higher-ASP gold products given the customer pool, accepting lower volume rather than holding lower price points and taking a bigger revenue hit.
- Omnichannel customers are stickier: 59% of new customer acquisition now happens on digital platforms, and omnichannel customers show significantly higher lifetime value than TV-only or digital-only buyers.
- Budget Pay deepens engagement: The installment-payment option now contributes 39% of total retail sales, enabling easier purchase and deeper customer engagement.
- Non-jewelry takes wallet share: Fashion accessories, lifestyle, beauty, apparel and home products constitute 27% of total retail revenue, helping capture more spend from the same household.
Agrawal: "Absolutely. It is transient and we are seeing this across U.S., U.K. It's not just U.K. has a little bit less impact because we acquired quite a lot of new customers because of new channel position. But otherwise, from the older channel distribution is similar behavior. So, it is the transient current environment."
Germany: Faster Path to Profitability
- Revenue scaling fast: The German business has grown exponentially, clocking monthly revenue of more than €0.1 crore in recent months, and recently started Live and Interactive shopping on its website and are seeing good customer traction.
- Gross margins ahead of legacy markets: Germany’s gross margins exceed those of the US and UK, partly because shipping revenue is lower and customers do not pay for return shipping, a market structure that yields higher gross margins.
- Repeat purchase beats expectations: German customers averaged 15 repeat purchases over the trailing twelve months, better than earlier estimates.
- EBITDA still negative but improving: The business continues to burn cash, but losses are slightly better in absolute euro terms versus Q2 FY22, and the burn is expected to keep shrinking in coming quarters.
- Profitability pulled forward by one year: Management originally expected a longer path to breakeven, but better-than-expected overall margins mean Germany will become profitable one year sooner than planned.
- Timeline: H1 of FY24 will still show a burn, H2 of FY24 is expected to be profitable, though the full FY24 year will still show a net burn.
- Monthly burn quantified: The current EBITDA burn runs at approximately €400,000 per month, and management expects the next coming quarters will be lower than that.
Agrawal: "When we launched, we didn't expect the consumer to be able to comfortably pay their higher margins, but they are doing. And that will become profitable 1 year sooner than we originally expected."
Margins: Bottoming Out and Rebuilding
- Sequential improvement from the trough: EBITDA margin at 8.1% improved from 7.0% in Q1, though it remains well below the 11.4% reported in Q2 FY22. Management stated margins had bottomed out in Q1.
- Three investments compressing near-term margins: Judicious spending on Germany, new OTA homes and digital marketing are building blocks expected to generate significant operating leverage in the medium and long term.
- Gross margin held within range: Gross margin at 60.9% stayed inside the guided 60–65% band, though some dilution occurred from the subdued business environment and cost increases like shipping that could not be fully passed through.
- Prior-year gross margin was inflated: Part of last year’s very high gross margin came from essentials like masks and other high-margin COVID-era products that have now normalized.
- Cost savings program underway: A $5 million to $7 million cost savings initiative is already delivering, with some benefit reflected in the sequential margin improvement; the larger portion is weighted to H2 and is already factored into full-year EBITDA guidance.
- US and UK margins also suppressed: Both legacy markets are running below their potential due to the macro environment, not just Germany; if US and UK margins were stable at last year’s levels, the German burn impact would be less noticeable.
- Operating leverage expected next year: Management expects both the US and UK to improve margins in the next financial year as leverage kicks in.
Agrawal: "Our judicious investments in Germany, new OTA homes and digital marketing have a short-term EBITDA impact. But these investments are building blocks, which will result in significant operating leverage in the medium and long-term."
Distribution & Customer Acquisition
- OTA reach expanded materially: The company added key cable markets to its distribution portfolio during the quarter, bringing in an additional 1 crore households in the US across OTA and cable TV platforms.
- Digital now dominates new acquisition: 59% of new customer acquisition happened on digital platforms during the quarter, reflecting sustained investment in omnichannel distribution.
- UK Freeview upgrade paying off: The channel position upgrade turned new TV customer acquisition from negative 17% in February 2022 to positive 49%, though the Queen’s death temporarily muted the benefit.
- New channel opportunities secured: Additional distribution opportunities were locked in over the last two quarters, entering new markets, though access to full-power OTA and further cable homes depends on channels being vacated by other players and the ability to bid at a fair price.
- Germany Live TV shopping launched: The company recently started Live and Interactive shopping on its German website and intends to increase coverage if trends remain positive.
Balance Sheet & Cash Flow
- PAT halved YoY: Profit after tax fell to ₹23 crore from ₹42 crore in Q2 FY22, reflecting the margin compression and investment phase.
- Cash generation improved: Operating cash flows reached ₹77 crore and free cash flows ₹62 crore, continuing a YoY improvement driven by CapEx normalizing, efficient capital allocation and cost focus.
- Return ratios compressed: Trailing-twelve-month ROE stood at 13% and ROCE at 18%, reflecting the conscious investments in affiliates, digital marketing, German operations and the broader economic environment.
- Two interim dividends declared: The Board declared an interim dividend of ₹1.50 per share for the quarter and a second interim dividend of ₹1.50 per share, signaling confidence in the cash position despite earnings pressure.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Full-year revenue growth | 2% to 4% top-line growth | FY23 |
| Full-year EBITDA margin | 8% to 9% including Germany burn | FY23 |
| Gross margin floor | 60%-plus | Coming period |
| Germany H2 profitability | H2 profitable, full year still net burn | FY24 |
| Germany breakeven acceleration | Profitable one year sooner than originally expected | No revised date given |
| US and UK margin recovery | Leverage and margin improvement | Next financial year (FY24) |
| Medium-term revenue growth | Mid-teens with operating leverage | Subsequent years (post-FY23) |
| Medium-term EBITDA margin | Double-digit | Medium-term |
| ASP normalization | Return to ~$20 from current $35 | Once inflationary and recessionary environment passes |
| Cost savings program | $5 million to $7 million total, larger benefit in H2 | FY23 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹646 cr, +1.8% YoY and +33% vs pre-COVID Q2 FY20 |
| Gross margin | 60.9%, vs 60%-plus guided range; product mix and cost pressures |
| EBITDA margin | 8.1%, vs 7.0% in Q1 FY23 and 11.4% in Q2 FY22 |
| Profit after-tax | ₹23 cr, vs ₹42 cr in Q2 FY22 |
| FY23 revenue growth guidance | 2% to 4% |
| FY23 EBITDA margin guidance | 8% to 9%, including Germany burn |
| Medium-term revenue growth outlook | Mid-teens, in subsequent years |
| TV revenue | ₹397 cr, +2.1% YoY and +27% vs pre-COVID Q2 FY20 |
| Digital revenue | ₹233 cr, +3.1% YoY and +57% vs pre-COVID Q2 FY20 |
| TV homes reach | ~13.5 cr, +23% YoY |
| New customer acquisition (TTM) | ₹2.5 lakhs, +9.8% YoY and +16.3% over Q2 FY21 |
| New customer acquisition on digital platforms | 59% of total new customers during the quarter |
| Budget Pay sales contribution | 39% of total retail sales |
| Non-jewelry segment share | 27% of total retail revenues |
| Germany monthly revenue run rate | >€0.1 cr in recent months |
| Germany monthly EBITDA burn | ~€400,000, expected to decline sequentially |
| TTM ROE | 13% |
| TTM ROCE | 18% |
| Operating cash flows | ₹77 cr |
| Free cash flows | ₹62 cr |
| Interim dividend per share | ₹1.50, second interim dividend for the fiscal year |