Key Takeaways
- Revenue hit by one-off shocks, not structural decline: Sales fell 3.6% YoY to ₹724 crores, but management says the quarter would have been flattish YoY absent a November cyber-attack and UK delivery strikes.
- Margins have bottomed and are turning up: EBITDA margin improved sequentially to 10.5% from 8.1% in Q2, and management states margins "already bottomed out" with year-over-year expansion ahead.
- Germany is the growth bet, nearing breakeven: The business is running at ~€1.4 mn monthly revenue with a 96% CSAT score, and management expects operating breakeven in H2 FY24 at ~€3 mn per month.
- FY24 guided to 8–10% revenue growth with strong operating leverage: Confidence rests on Germany scaling, US airtime additions, digital investments, and D2C brands tracking better.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the guided Q4 flattish-to-2% growth materialises, the pace of EBITDA margin recovery toward the 15% ambition, and any consumer sentiment stabilisation in the US and UK.
The Quarter's Damage: Cyber-Attack, Strikes, and Weak Demand
- Cyber-attack froze operations: A 12 November attack on US and UK servers disrupted business almost completely for ~2 days; online was back within 24 hours, TV after 2 days, and shipments were blocked for roughly one week.
- UK delivery strikes compounded the hit: Industry-wide postal disruption added to the drag, making the quarter's revenue decline a story of transient shocks layered on soft demand.
- Recovery was fast: All apps were moved to the cloud post-attack, and security was beefed up through CISA and Sophos; management noted that typical recovery from such attacks takes about two weeks.
- Underlying demand was flattish: Without the cyber-attack and delivery disruption, revenue would have been flattish YoY, meaning the core business held its ground despite inflationary pressure on consumers.
Sunil Agrawal: "had this attack & delivery disruption did not happen our revenue would have been flattish YoY."
Geography & Channel: US and UK Soft, Germany Rising, Digital Steady
- US (Shop LC) bore the brunt: Local currency sales declined 11.3% YoY because weak consumer sentiment and the cyber-attack outweighed any benefit from inflation inching downwards.
- UK (Shop TJC) also declined: Revenue fell 10.9% YoY as weak consumer sentiment overshadowed growth prospects, partly affected by the cyber-attack and delivery market disruption; the Freeview channel upgrade continues to drive new TV customer acquisition, with YoY growth every month after being negative prior to the upgrade.
- Germany sustained momentum: The business clocked ~€1.4 mn revenue per month, dispatching over 3,500 pieces a day, with a 96% CSAT score; broadcasting covers Austria as well, treated as a combined market.
- Digital held flat, TV declined: TV revenue declined 5.5% YoY to ₹441 crores while digital revenue grew 0.4% to ₹269 crores; focused omni-channel investments helped digital's relative resilience.
- Omni-channel customers are the prize: ~59% of new customers were acquired digitally, and omni-channel customers have significantly higher lifetime value than TV-only or digital-only customers.
Margins & Cost Structure: Bottom Reached, Leverage Ahead
- Gross margin held at 60.6%: The vertically integrated business model allows product differentiation with lower ASP, and management will not entertain products or brands with gross margin below 60%.
- EBITDA margin turned up sequentially: Improved to 10.5% in Q3 from 8.1% in Q2, driven by sustained cost optimisation; management stated margins bottomed out in Q4 FY22 and have now entered a year-over-year expansion phase.
- Germany is the main margin drag vs pre-COVID: EBITDA margin is significantly lower than pre-COVID December quarters mainly because of investment in Germany, plus investments in digital and broadcasting.
- Broadcasting cost target set: Management aims to bring TV broadcasting cost to 10–12% of revenue within 18 months; in the US, ~1.5 crore cable/OTA homes remain unreached, and the company will continue to take opportunistic broadcast deals.
- Budget pay supports affordability: Products sold via budget pay contributed 38% of total retail revenues, adding affordability during the inflationary environment and improving customer engagement.
Sunil Agrawal: "...we already bottomed out from a margin point of view. As you saw in current quarter, we're already double digit. So, year-over-year, our margins will continue to expand."
Product & Brand Strategy: Own Brands, Low Price Points, Ethical Sourcing
- Non-jewellery is a growing share: Fashion accessories, lifestyle, beauty, and apparel now contribute 28% of total revenue, a multifold increase over the last few years.
- Rachel Galley surged on a low base: The D2C brand delivered 200% YoY revenue growth.
- $10/$20 products are being accelerated: In response to current economic sentiments, the company is leaning into lower price points, which drive higher customer acquisition, better engagement, and low return rates; gross margin stays above 60% because 50% is the absolute floor.
- Ethical sourcing, not copying: If an external supplier presents an interesting new product, the company will buy from them rather than copy and manufacture it themselves; if a product line scales enough to sustain own manufacturing, the company will then invest in making it.
- Brand exclusion is deliberate: The 60% gross margin threshold excludes brands like Apple, Samsung, or Dell; management is happy to stay in a space where its own brands become more ubiquitous over time.
Sunil Agrawal: "if it is lesser than that, we just don't entertain that brand. So that in fact would exclude, say, Apple or Samsung or Dell products for us. And we are happy to stay in the space where our brands would, over the years, become more ubiquitous"
Germany: The Path to Breakeven and Beyond
- Breakeven expected in H2 FY24: Management is comfortable that Germany will reach operating breakeven in the second half of the next financial year at ~€3 mn per month in net revenue; the full year FY24 will not be profitable, but FY25 should be profitable for the full year.
- Inflation delayed profitability: If not for the inflationary and subdued demand environment, Germany would have been profitable earlier.
- Overall leverage absorbs Germany losses: Even after accounting for Germany's losses, management expects strong year-over-year operating leverage next year.
- Next market is Japan, not India: Once Germany is successful, profitable, and scaling well, the company may look at Japan next, approximately three years from now; India is not on the near-term roadmap because long-distance shopping there is still unprofitable and in the discovery phase.
Sunil Agrawal: "once Germany is successful and profitable and scaling well, we may look at Japan next before coming to India."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Q4 FY23 revenue | Flattish to 2% growth | Q4 FY23 |
| Full FY23 revenue | Negative 3% to negative 2% growth | FY23 |
| FY24 revenue growth | 8% to 10% growth with strong operating leverage over FY23 | FY24 |
| Germany operating breakeven | At ~€3 mn per month net revenue | H2 FY24 |
| Germany full-year profitability | Full year profitable | FY25 |
| TV broadcasting cost | 10% to 12% of revenue | Within 18 months |
| Digital customer acquisition cost | Acquire customers at one-third of lifetime value | Ongoing target |
| Gross margin floor | Will not entertain products/brands below 60% gross margin | Ongoing principle |
| Mid-term revenue growth | Mid-teens revenue growth with decent operating leverage | Mid-term |
| EBITDA margin ambition | Get back to ~15% "as soon as possible"; next year won't be 15% but strong leverage over current year | Medium-term |
| Japan market entry | May look at Japan after Germany is successful, profitable, and scaling | ~3 years from now |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹724 cr, down 3.6% YoY from ₹750 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Revenue growth vs pre-COVID Q3 FY20 | 28.5% |
| Gross margin | 60.6% |
| EBITDA margin | 10.5%, vs 8.1% in Q2 FY23 and 11.4% in Q3 FY22 |
| Profit after tax | ₹39 cr, vs ₹69 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Operating cashflow | ₹121 cr, YoY improvement |
| Free cashflow | ₹96 cr, YoY improvement |
| ROE (TTM) | 9.5% |
| ROCE (TTM) | 14.5% |
| Interim dividend per share | ₹1.50 |
| FY24 revenue growth guidance | 8% to 10% |
| Mid-term revenue growth outlook | mid-teens |
| TV homes reach | ~12.9 crore, ~2% higher YoY |
| Shop LC (US) local currency sales decline | 11.3% YoY, majorly driven by weak consumer sentiments and cyber-attack |
| Shop TJC (UK) revenue decline | 10.9% YoY, partly affected by cyber-attack and delivery disruption |
| TV revenue | ₹441 cr, declined 5.5% YoY |
| Digital revenue | ₹269 cr, grew 0.4% YoY |
| Digital revenue growth vs pre-COVID Q3 FY20 | 50.2% |
| New customers acquired digitally | ~59% of total new customers |
| Budget pay contribution to retail revenue | 38% |
| Non-jewellery revenue share | 28% |
| Unique customer base | ~0.05 crore |
| New customer registrations (TTM) | 3.2 lakh |
| New customer acquisition (TTM) | 2.4 lakh, lower by 1% YoY, higher by 79% over pre-COVID Q3 FY20 |
| Germany monthly revenue run rate | ~€1.4 million |
| Germany daily dispatch volume | >3,500 pieces |
| Germany CSAT score | 96% |
| Germany operating break-even expected | H2 of FY24 |
| Rachel Galley D2C brand revenue growth | 200% YoY on a low base |
| Midday meals donated (cumulative milestone) | >7.3 crore, run rate ~54,000 meals per school day |
| Market share estimate | ~2% to 3%, as stated by analyst and confirmed by management |