Key Takeaways
- Subdued quarter, steady guide: Revenue grew just 1.1% YoY as macro headwinds hit discretionary demand across the UK and US, yet management guided FY24 revenue growth of 8–10% and expects Germany to break even by H2.
- Germany is the growth bet: A new Vodafone partnership added 1.3 crore households, taking reach to ~90% of Germany and Austria, and management is confident the market breaks even in H2 FY24 as new homes mature.
- Cash flow turned the corner: Operating cash flow improved to INR 126 crores and free cash flow swung from negative INR 214 crores to positive INR 90 crores, as capex normalized and shipping costs fell.
- Discretionary pain, market-share gain: Unique customers and retention slipped under macro pressure, but management insists it continued gaining share against listed competitors in every market.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the Vodafone ramp translates into customer additions and revenue, the pace of Germany’s march to breakeven, and any sign that ASP is normalizing as the macro environment stabilizes.
Demand & Consumer Health
- UK squeezed by cost of living: Gas prices, food costs and higher interest rates hit discretionary spend; the company responded by allocating more airtime to sub-£10 and sub-£20 products, where customer interaction improved.
- US sentiment weighed down: Macro challenges dampened demand, but the company continued adding TV cable and OTA households to expand reach.
- ASP rose on gold, not on strength: Higher ASP reflected inflation and increased interest in gold products like chains and rings; management views this as temporary and expects ASP to settle back as business normalizes.
- Unique customers dipped: The count fell from ~5 lakh to 461,000, driven by higher price points and the tough economic environment; management expects a meaningful increase in FY24 from Vodafone distribution and digital investments.
- Retention and repeat purchase softened: TTM repeat pieces fell to 23 from 27, and retention slipped to 38% from 40%, attributed to higher price points and the adverse economy.
Sunil Agrawal: "Our product is still not necessity. It is discretionary. And in such environment, discretionary product will take a hit for all retailers of discretionary product. Compared to other retailers, we continued to gain market share."
Germany: The Next Growth Engine
- Vodafone partnership transformed reach: The tie-up added 1.3 crore cable households, taking total coverage to ~90% of Germany and Austria within 1.5 years of launch.
- Revenue and customers scaling monthly: Germany was already growing every month before Vodafone; the partnership accelerated the trajectory further.
- Breakeven expected in H2 FY24: The current monthly loss is ~EUR 0.15 crore, rising to ~EUR 0.25 crore after Vodafone airtime costs; management needs an additional EUR 0.1 crore per month to break even and is confident based on repeat-purchase behaviour of existing and new customers.
- No additional capex needed: The path to breakeven requires no further investment beyond the existing opex commitment for broadcasting rights, which is paid monthly.
- Lifestyle share still low: Lifestyle products are 18–20% of Germany sales, lower than in the UK, because the company is initially more comfortable in jewellery given its 40-year manufacturing history.
Sunil Agrawal: "No, there's no other capex or additional opex needed to reach there because we are seeing the repeat purchase behaviour of customers that we have acquired previously. And when we extrapolate that behaviour on Vodafone or other customers, we reach to the same conclusion that we will reach breakeven in H2."
Margins & Cost Structure
- EBITDA margin improved YoY: Q4 EBITDA margin was 8% vs 6.9% in Q4 FY22, helped by efficient pricing, product mix and continuous cost rationalization; Q4 is always a linear period with margins lower than Q3.
- Gross margin held at 61%: The vertically integrated business model supported gross margins despite macro pressure.
- Shipping costs fell sharply: Q4 shipping cost was $6 million vs $9 million last year, and FY23 was $25 million vs $33 million, largely due to lower volume with some carrier renegotiations.
- Operating leverage expected in FY24: Employee costs and other expenses will increase but grow slower than revenue, delivering operating leverage; management declined to quantify specific expense heads.
- Digital auction margin is structurally lower: The $1 auction format clears TV inventory tails and dogs that cannot be returned to vendors, earning 15–20% margin vs 50–60% for live streaming and catalogue sales.
Sunil Agrawal: "We would strive to reach back or cross 15.3% that we achieved in FY '21, but we are not giving specific guidance how soon we'll reach that. But our effort would be to reach there as soon as possible."
Channel & Customer Dynamics
- Digital outperformed TV: Digital channels continued to perform better owing to wider discovery potential; omni-channel customers have significantly higher lifetime value than single-platform customers.
- OTT lifetime value is more than double TV: Once customers download the app and start interacting, stickiness around app behaviour drives far higher lifetime value than a cable or satellite home, though OTA homes have similar initial economics.
- TV audience is a deliberate niche: The core TV audience is 40-plus women who have time and seek company, education and live communication from hosts; this demographic remains the TV channel's focus.
- Salesforce integration went live: Marketing and service clouds are now integrated across the US and UK, enabling email, SMS, chat and website targeting for upsell, cross-sell and precise retargeting.
- New registrations held above pre-COVID: At 3 lakh vs 3.18 lakh in FY22, new registrations were 69% higher than pre-COVID levels despite the macro drag.
Sunil Agrawal: "So, our TV audience is largely 40-plus women who have time on their hand, and they have a need to get the company from live hosts from us. They have time on hand, and they are lonely. So, we give them a company, give them education, give them live communication."
Balance Sheet & Cash Flows
- Free cash flow turned positive: FCF swung to INR 90 crores from negative INR 214 crores in FY22, as capex reverted to normalized levels after the prior year's investment cycle.
- Operating cash flow improved: OCF rose to INR 126 crores in FY23 from INR 86 crores in FY22.
- Inventory declined in USD terms: Group-wide inventory fell from $84 million to $78 million; the INR increase was purely rupee devaluation.
- ROE and ROCE subdued: At 9.1% and 14.4% respectively, both metrics reflect the impact of subdued profitability during the year.
- Dividend maintained: The board recommended a final dividend of INR 1.5 per share, taking the total FY23 payout to INR 6 per equity share.
Strategic Initiatives
- Own-brand target of 50% by FY27: The current mix is ~30%; the objective is better customer affinity and retention, not meaningfully higher margins.
- D2C brands growing but investment on hold: TAMSY and Rachel Galley grew YoY from a small base, with marketing spend as a ratio of revenue improving, but earlier investment plans were paused due to the macro environment.
- B2B filled idle capacity: Manufacturing capacity was underutilized as retail units did not fully lift product when ASP rose; the company approached other retailers who placed orders, and it will continue these relationships as long as ROCE is delivered.
- US distribution expanded: An additional 0.4 crore new homes were added in the US during the quarter.
- Sustainability milestones: The SEZ unit in Jaipur was certified as a net zero energy building (one of only 15 in India), cumulative solar generation crossed 1.1 crore units, and 184 e-scooters distributed to employees cut 12 buses from the fleet and approximately 70 tons of carbon emissions per year.
Sunil Agrawal: "I remember saying that and I still stand by of gaining market share in any environment, whether it is a recessionary environment or economically robust environment that we'll continue to gain the market share owing to our value proposition."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 8% to 10% on a constant-currency basis | FY24 |
| Germany breakeven | Achieve monthly breakeven; no additional capex or opex required beyond existing Vodafone airtime costs | H2 FY24 |
| Operating leverage | Employee costs and other expenses to grow slower than revenue | FY24 |
| Own-brand revenue mix | Reach 50% of revenue mix | By FY27 |
| Carbon neutrality | Scope 1 and Scope 2 greenhouse gas emissions | By FY31 |
| EBITDA margin aspiration | Strive to reach back or cross 15.3% (FY21 level); no specific timeline given | Not dated |
| Mid-teen revenue growth | Expected in subsequent periods with decent operating leverage | Post-FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹693 cr, +1.1% YoY; +39.2% vs Q4 FY20 (11.7% CAGR) |
| Shop LC US sales decline (local currency) | 12.1% YoY |
| Shop TJC UK sales decline (local currency) | 4.6% YoY |
| TV revenue | ₹409 cr, -1.7% YoY |
| Digital revenue | ₹256 cr, +2.1% YoY |
| Gross margin | 61% |
| EBITDA margin | 8%, vs 6.9% in Q4 FY22 |
| Profit after-tax | ₹23 cr, vs ₹27 cr in Q4 FY22 |
| FY23 revenue growth guidance | 8% to 10% in FY24, constant currency |
| FY23 operating cash flow | ₹126 cr, vs ₹86 cr in FY22 |
| FY23 free cash flow | ₹90 cr, vs negative ₹214 cr in FY22 |
| ROE | 9.1% |
| ROCE | 14.4% |
| Dividend per share (total FY23) | ₹6.0, including ₹1.5 final dividend recommended |
| TV homes reach | 14.1 crore, +14% YoY |
| New registrations (12 months) | 3 lakh, vs 3.18 lakh in FY22; +69% over pre-COVID |
| Digital customer acquisition | 57% of new customers, vs 56% in FY22 |
| Average pieces per customer (TTM) | 23, vs 27 in prior year |
| Retention rate (TTM) | 38%, vs 40% in FY22 |
| Unique customers (FY23) | 461,000 |
| Jewellery share of retail sales | 73% |
| Budget pay revenue mix (FY23) | 39% of retail revenue |
| Germany quarterly loss | €0.15 cr, flattish YoY in local currency |
| Germany breakeven sales gap | ~$1 mn additional net sales per month needed |
| Germany current monthly run rate | ~€0.25 cr post-Vodafone; breakeven at ~€0.35 cr |
| Shipping cost (quarter) | $6 mn, vs $9 mn in Q4 FY22 |
| Shipping cost (full year) | $25 mn, vs $33 mn in FY22 |
| Content and broadcasting cost (FY23) | ₹273 cr, vs ₹233 cr in FY22 |
| Group inventory (USD) | $78 mn, down from $84 mn YoY |
| OTT customer lifetime value | ~$1,500, vs ~$800 on TV |
| Own-brand revenue mix | ~30%, target 50% by FY27 |