V-Guard Industries Ltd Q2 FY2023 Concall Summary

Source transcript PDF: https://assets.stockscans.in/docs/cm9vukhywto02e0g626y4cii.pdf

Key Takeaways


Margin Walk: The Copper Overhang and Pricing Gaps

Mithun Chittilappilly: "In the Consumer Durables segment, both in the Fans and Water Heaters businesses, the business units and their margins are impacted. They are largely on account of pricing gaps, in the sense that the commodity prices have gone up to some degree and the players in the market, due to whatever reason — may be hyper-competition, poor season, whatever it is — are not passing on the full effect into the market."

Demand: Destocking, Rural Stress, and the Festive Miss

V. Ramachandran: "I think it is fair to say that there is a stress on demand in rural markets, smaller towns or entry-level products. That definitely has been there for some time now. I have seen that from the early stage of the commodity run-up and it was initially reflecting in stress for passing input cost increases. So the companies were stressed in terms of margins on entry level products because of the inability of the market to absorb."

Segment Performance

SegmentTrendCommentary
Consumer Durables▲ Strong growthAided by smaller, faster-growing categories like Kitchen Appliances and Fans where V-Guard is small versus market leaders and growing faster; however, margin compression continued due to pricing gaps.
Electronics▲ Improved trajectorySustained its improved growth trajectory; four-year CAGR of ~7%, lagging other segments because COVID impacted summer months over the last two years.
Electricals▬ Nearly flatPrice reductions in Wires linked to the dip in copper prices offset volume performance.
Water Heaters▲ Growth but below planRegained all market share lost a couple of years ago but still needs to catch up on a lost year; growth was less than anticipated but probably still faster than the market.
FansMixedEntry-level sales stressed over the last year to year-and-a-half, pushing mid and premium share to over 50%; BLDC category growing but trade up-stocking slowed by BEE transition.

Geographic Rebalancing and Channel Expansion


Inventory: The Bridge to Margin Recovery

Mithun Chittilappilly: "I think in COVID what happened is that there was an expansion of gross margin also, because initially the copper prices, I mean the commodity prices came down and then it shot up. So what we will look at is probably the pre-COVID margin number."

Competitive Dynamics and Strategic Bets

Mithun Chittilappilly: "We also found that these are transient issues and after some time, people do understand that cutting prices is zero-sum game because everyone else will also do the same and then finally, there is very little evidence that someone will actually gain market share by cutting prices."

Guidance & Commitments

CommitmentSpecificsTimeline
Gross margin recoveryRevert to pre-COVID normative levels, provided current cost environment and prices remain where they areBy end of Q4 FY23
Consumer Durables gross marginReach pre-COVID levels as older materials are consumed and fresh raw materials purchasedBy end of Q4 FY23
Fans high-cost inventoryExhaust existing high-cost inventoryBy end of Q3 FY23
Inventory daysReduce significantly from current elevated levels back toward 70–75 daysBy end of current quarter (Q3 FY23)
BEE norm trade up-stockingTrade will up-stock across brands because brands must stop selling old-norm productsDuring Q3 FY23, before 31st December deadline
Fan pricing with new BEE normsNew models positioned at 5–8% higher prices depending on segmentAt BEE transition
Kitchen Appliances manufacturing facilityFacility to come up to enhance competitiveness12–18 months
Three new plantsConstruction to complete; ₹70 crores CapEx earmarkedOver 18 months; FY23 and FY24
Simon mergerNCLT-driven merger to completeNext quarter (Q4 FY23)
Channel expansionContinue adding 5,000–6,000 outlets per yearOngoing
Revenue growth target15% per annum, with ongoing investments in manufacturing, talent, and technologyOngoing

Key Metrics

MetricQ2 FY23
Revenue₹980 cr, 8.6% YoY growth, 16.6% three-year CAGR
South markets YoY growth2.6%
Non-South markets YoY growth17.8%
Non-South revenue contribution42.7%, up from 39.4% in Q2 FY22
Gross margin29.2%, down 210 bps YoY
EBITDA margin7.4%, down from 10.5% in Q2 FY22
EBITDA margin excluding copper impact~9% (per management estimate); ₹16 cr copper-related hit
A&P spends2.2% of revenue, up from 1.5% in Q2 FY22
H1 turnover increase36%
Revenue growth at constant wire prices~11% to 11.5% (per management estimate)
Consumer Durables steady-state gross margin~20%, higher than company average pre-COVID
Fans mid and premium portfolio share40–50%, up from ~40% previously
BEE norm change: entry-segment fan price increase~5%; newer models positioned 5–8% higher
Electronics segment four-year CAGR~7%
Company three-year CAGR15%
Channel expansion rate5,000–6,000 outlets added per year
South vs Non-South distribution coverage60–65% of journey covered
Gross margin gap from normative levels2.5–3%
High-cost inventory liquidation timeline~4 months
CapEx earmarked for FY23 and FY24₹70 cr; some part already spent in FY23
Manufacturing footprint expansion completion12–18 months
New manufacturing entity tax rate~17%
ETR benefit expected~2% reduction in FY25; FY24 to see some reduction but not significant
Inventory days target70–75 days; currently holding ~20 days more than pre-COVID levels