Key Takeaways
- Revenue up 8.6% but demand softened late: YoY growth was solid, yet the 30–45 day run-up to the festive period fell short of plan, with sell-out stress visible in Consumer Durables.
- Gross margin dropped 210 bps to 29.2%: A ₹16 crores copper-inventory hit and pricing gaps in Consumer Durables compressed margins; without the copper impact, EBITDA margin would have been close to 9% instead of 7.4%.
- Non-South now 42.7% of revenue: The 17.8% YoY growth outside the South is creating a more balanced geographic portfolio, with future operating-leverage benefits as channel expansion continues.
- High-cost inventory is the margin bridge: Management expects gross margin to revert to pre-COVID levels by Q4 as higher-cost inventory (especially in Fans) is consumed and fresh purchases reflect softer input prices.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the BEE norm transition triggers the expected trade up-stocking in Q3, the pace of inventory normalisation toward 70–75 days, and any demand signal from post-Diwali trade replenishment.
Margin Walk: The Copper Overhang and Pricing Gaps
- Copper-driven inventory loss: A ₹16 crores hit flowed through the P&L because selling prices were reduced while the company was still carrying higher-cost copper inventory; this impact was concentrated in July and the first half of August.
- Wires margins already normalised: Once the high-cost copper inventory was exhausted, Wires margins returned to normal in September, demonstrating the mechanical nature of the recovery where inventory turns are faster.
- Consumer Durables margin compression: Pricing gaps versus input-cost increases persisted because market players did not fully pass on commodity rises, citing hyper-competition or a poor season; Fans saw a sharper impact from elevated aluminium prices due to the war.
- Accounting shift from in-house manufacturing: As own manufacturing scales up (36% turnover increase in H1), costs are shifting from material margin to other expense lines like freight and warranty, altering segment-level margin presentation.
- Company-level gross margin off 2.5–3% from normative: Price reductions since May have been almost in that same range; recovery will happen as high-cost inventory sells out and new purchases are made at current commodity prices.
- Fans recovery will take longer: The company is holding high-cost inventory primarily in Fans, expected to be exhausted only by end of Q3, which means margin improvement in that category is back-end loaded.
Mithun Chittilappilly: "In the Consumer Durables segment, both in the Fans and Water Heaters businesses, the business units and their margins are impacted. They are largely on account of pricing gaps, in the sense that the commodity prices have gone up to some degree and the players in the market, due to whatever reason — may be hyper-competition, poor season, whatever it is — are not passing on the full effect into the market."
Demand: Destocking, Rural Stress, and the Festive Miss
- Late-quarter slowdown: In the 30–45 days leading up to the festive period, the company fell short of its plan; some stress in sell-out was visible, particularly in Consumer Durables where planned selling did not materialise.
- Wire sales slowed by trade destocking: As copper prices fell, the trade reduced inventory to manage risk, waiting for copper to bottom out before restocking; this is a destocking phenomenon, not underlying demand weakness.
- Fans channel behaviour: Trade was slower to up-stock even on growing categories like BLDC because they were focused on liquidating old-energy-standard fans ahead of the BEE norm transition.
- Rural and entry-level stress is structural, not new: Stress on demand in rural markets, smaller towns, and entry-level products has been present for 12–18 months, initially reflecting the inability to pass on input-cost increases to price-sensitive consumers.
- Channel inventory rose but not alarming: Some increase in days of channel inventory reflected the slowdown in the last 30–45 days; described as manageable.
- Real estate demand a bit slower: Difficult to derive a clear signal because V-Guard is not a very big player in Switches and Switch Gears, and most sales in those categories are primarily retail.
V. Ramachandran: "I think it is fair to say that there is a stress on demand in rural markets, smaller towns or entry-level products. That definitely has been there for some time now. I have seen that from the early stage of the commodity run-up and it was initially reflecting in stress for passing input cost increases. So the companies were stressed in terms of margins on entry level products because of the inability of the market to absorb."
Segment Performance
| Segment | Trend | Commentary |
|---|---|---|
| Consumer Durables | ▲ Strong growth | Aided by smaller, faster-growing categories like Kitchen Appliances and Fans where V-Guard is small versus market leaders and growing faster; however, margin compression continued due to pricing gaps. |
| Electronics | ▲ Improved trajectory | Sustained its improved growth trajectory; four-year CAGR of ~7%, lagging other segments because COVID impacted summer months over the last two years. |
| Electricals | ▬ Nearly flat | Price reductions in Wires linked to the dip in copper prices offset volume performance. |
| Water Heaters | ▲ Growth but below plan | Regained all market share lost a couple of years ago but still needs to catch up on a lost year; growth was less than anticipated but probably still faster than the market. |
| Fans | Mixed | Entry-level sales stressed over the last year to year-and-a-half, pushing mid and premium share to over 50%; BLDC category growing but trade up-stocking slowed by BEE transition. |
Geographic Rebalancing and Channel Expansion
- Non-South grew 17.8% YoY: Revenue share rose to 42.7% from 39.4%, creating a more balanced geographic portfolio; South grew only 2.6% YoY.
- Channel expansion continues at pace: The company plans to add 5,000–6,000 outlets per year, with significant scope remaining in Non-South for both reach and throughput improvement.
- Future operating leverage: The geographic rebalancing is expected to yield operating-leverage benefits as the Non-South footprint matures and distribution density improves.
Inventory: The Bridge to Margin Recovery
- Inventory days elevated: Currently holding ~20 days more inventory than pre-COVID levels; the normal operating level is 70–75 days.
- Reduction slower than planned: Lower September sales meant inventory reduction proceeded slower than anticipated; the company intends to revert to normative stock levels in the coming months, though it may take longer than planned.
- High-cost inventory concentrated in Consumer Durables: Wires recovers faster because less inventory is carried; Consumer Durables (and some Inverter Battery) is where more stress sits and recovery will be slower.
- Fans high-cost inventory exhausts by end of Q3: This means margin improvement in Fans will take more time compared to Wires, where margins already normalised in September.
Mithun Chittilappilly: "I think in COVID what happened is that there was an expansion of gross margin also, because initially the copper prices, I mean the commodity prices came down and then it shot up. So what we will look at is probably the pre-COVID margin number."
Competitive Dynamics and Strategic Bets
- Hyper-competition is transient and category-specific: Management described price wars as a zero-sum game where realisation eventually sets in; cited Kitchen Appliances (hyper-competitive 4–5 years ago, now mellowed) and Water Heaters (was hyper-competitive, now mellowing) as evidence.
- Kitchen Appliances manufacturing facility: Being put in place, expected to come up in the next 12–18 months to enhance competitiveness.
- Water Purifiers still early stage: Expanding product portfolio and lineup; current focus is e-commerce to build comfort on competitiveness before moving to organised retail and then general trade.
- Simon brand acquisition: Merger is still in process, NCLT-driven; not yet materialised on the ground; expected to complete in another couple of months, with an update likely next quarter.
- Three plants under construction: Will take over 18 months to complete; ₹70 crores CapEx earmarked for FY23 and FY24.
- Export strategy deprioritised for Stabilizers: Management believes focusing energy on the Indian market and building V-Guard as a consumer brand in Electricals and Consumer Durables is more value-creating than pursuing export opportunities in competitive markets like Africa.
Mithun Chittilappilly: "We also found that these are transient issues and after some time, people do understand that cutting prices is zero-sum game because everyone else will also do the same and then finally, there is very little evidence that someone will actually gain market share by cutting prices."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Gross margin recovery | Revert to pre-COVID normative levels, provided current cost environment and prices remain where they are | By end of Q4 FY23 |
| Consumer Durables gross margin | Reach pre-COVID levels as older materials are consumed and fresh raw materials purchased | By end of Q4 FY23 |
| Fans high-cost inventory | Exhaust existing high-cost inventory | By end of Q3 FY23 |
| Inventory days | Reduce significantly from current elevated levels back toward 70–75 days | By end of current quarter (Q3 FY23) |
| BEE norm trade up-stocking | Trade will up-stock across brands because brands must stop selling old-norm products | During Q3 FY23, before 31st December deadline |
| Fan pricing with new BEE norms | New models positioned at 5–8% higher prices depending on segment | At BEE transition |
| Kitchen Appliances manufacturing facility | Facility to come up to enhance competitiveness | 12–18 months |
| Three new plants | Construction to complete; ₹70 crores CapEx earmarked | Over 18 months; FY23 and FY24 |
| Simon merger | NCLT-driven merger to complete | Next quarter (Q4 FY23) |
| Channel expansion | Continue adding 5,000–6,000 outlets per year | Ongoing |
| Revenue growth target | 15% per annum, with ongoing investments in manufacturing, talent, and technology | Ongoing |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹980 cr, 8.6% YoY growth, 16.6% three-year CAGR |
| South markets YoY growth | 2.6% |
| Non-South markets YoY growth | 17.8% |
| Non-South revenue contribution | 42.7%, up from 39.4% in Q2 FY22 |
| Gross margin | 29.2%, down 210 bps YoY |
| EBITDA margin | 7.4%, down from 10.5% in Q2 FY22 |
| EBITDA margin excluding copper impact | ~9% (per management estimate); ₹16 cr copper-related hit |
| A&P spends | 2.2% of revenue, up from 1.5% in Q2 FY22 |
| H1 turnover increase | 36% |
| Revenue growth at constant wire prices | ~11% to 11.5% (per management estimate) |
| Consumer Durables steady-state gross margin | ~20%, higher than company average pre-COVID |
| Fans mid and premium portfolio share | 40–50%, up from ~40% previously |
| BEE norm change: entry-segment fan price increase | ~5%; newer models positioned 5–8% higher |
| Electronics segment four-year CAGR | ~7% |
| Company three-year CAGR | 15% |
| Channel expansion rate | 5,000–6,000 outlets added per year |
| South vs Non-South distribution coverage | 60–65% of journey covered |
| Gross margin gap from normative levels | 2.5–3% |
| High-cost inventory liquidation timeline | ~4 months |
| CapEx earmarked for FY23 and FY24 | ₹70 cr; some part already spent in FY23 |
| Manufacturing footprint expansion completion | 12–18 months |
| New manufacturing entity tax rate | ~17% |
| ETR benefit expected | ~2% reduction in FY25; FY24 to see some reduction but not significant |
| Inventory days target | 70–75 days; currently holding ~20 days more than pre-COVID levels |