Key Takeaways
- Subdued quarter, internal problems cited: Revenue grew only 6% against an industry growing 20–25%, which management attributes squarely to internal execution issues, not market weakness.
- Gross margin hit 55% target, giving confidence: The structural milestone was reached this quarter, driven by better mix and lower crude costs, and management sees a sustainable 53%–55% range going forward.
- Leadership reset underway: The sudden exit of the MD prompted the board to elevate the CFO to the role; the new MD is 60 days in and asking for time to deliver results rather than promises.
- CapEx pivot signals a strategic shift: The planned ₹200 crore soft luggage expansion is on hold; instead, ₹50 crore is going into hard luggage capacity, where demand is outstripping supply.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the 26 new product launches and improved fill rates actually close the gap to market growth, and any sign that the elevated inventory can be worked down without deep discounting.
The Growth Gap: Why VIP Missed While the Industry Surged
- Internal execution, not demand: Management explicitly blamed its own problems for the 6% revenue growth while the industry grew 20–25%, citing two root causes: a botched supply chain shift from China to Bangladesh that hurt the premium mix, and frequent top-level management changes that disrupted long-term strategy.
- Bangladesh misstep: The company overestimated Bangladesh's ability to match Chinese manufacturing excellence in premium products; China has refined this over 30 years, and VIP tried to replicate it in one year, leading to an adverse brand mix that its overhead structure cannot support.
- Volume vs value: Volume growth of 10% was healthier than the 6% revenue growth, implying a mix shift toward lower-priced product, consistent with the premium supply shortfall.
- Channel-specific drags: CSD and CPC channels dragged performance, with a portfolio refresh for CSD still taking time to convert into revenue.
- International headwinds: Demand slowed in international markets, and an improved supply chain in China further hurt VIP's international business.
- Recovery timeline: The new MD expects to reach market growth "immediately, but in one or two quarters," pinning the turnaround on 26 new launches over the next 3–4 months and solving fill rates.
Neetu Kashiramka: "I would attribute this to our own internal problems and nothing else. However, I'm also confident that we should be able to get to the market growth immediately, but in one or two quarters."
Gross Margin: The 55% Milestone and What It Cost
- Target achieved: Gross margin reached 55% this quarter, a structural goal that management says takes longer to build than addressing fixed costs, giving them confidence in its durability.
- Drivers: A 2% improvement in premium mix and the full impact of crude price reductions from six months ago flowed through this quarter.
- The e-commerce caveat: Gross margin adjusted for performance marketing spend was 51% in Q2; management expects the 53%–55% range to hold going forward because e-commerce salience will not stay at 30%+ every quarter and the premium mix is rising.
- Channel margin hierarchy: Retail delivers the highest gross margins, followed by general trade; modern trade and e-commerce sit at the lower end and are similar to each other. Contribution margins after channel-specific costs differ by only 2–3% between modern trade and e-commerce, and e-commerce is already contribution-positive.
- Growth vs margin trade-off: The new MD is comfortable at 55% and would deploy any additional gross margin upside toward reviving growth rather than letting it fall to the bottom line.
Neetu Kashiramka: "I think 55% number I'm comfortable with and if there's any additional thing then I may look at using that money to revive growth."
Leadership Transition: A CFO Steps Up Amid Sale Rumours
- Sudden change: Mr. Anindya Dutta resigned abruptly; the board unanimously promoted Ms. Neetu Kashiramka from CFO to MD approximately 60 days before this call.
- The confidence question: When asked what initiatives give confidence in the market share and margin improvement narrative, the promoter declined to offer specifics, stating it is "time for actions more than words" and that performance over coming quarters must do the talking.
- Sale rumour addressed directly: Radhika Piramal acknowledged her father has received many PE offers over decades, that a sale is possible in the future, but "it's not happening today, not happening tomorrow" and the new MD is fully focused on improving performance for the short, medium and long term.
- Management churn explained: Constant top-level changes were attributed to COVID-era volatility and high-performing individuals not wanting to endure the downturn; one recent departure had been with the company since 2013 and saw revenue fall back to 2013 levels in 2020 through no fault of his own.
- No guidance yet: The new MD declined to give growth guidance, saying it is too early; after one or two quarters she may be able to guide for the following fiscal year.
Radhika Piramal: "I think the thing that will give the confidence is performance over the coming quarters, so we look forward to that and all I can say is that many of you are investment professionals. Some of you have known Neetu for many years. So everybody can make their own view as to the likelihood of her success personally, I remain extremely confident."
Inventory Overhang: Betting on Backpack Season
- Overstocked and mispositioned: The company anticipated very high growth in Q1 and Q2 that did not materialize, leaving it with high inventories concentrated in backpacks and soft luggage uprights that lack fashionable new designs.
- Carrying cost pain: The inventory overhang drove up freight and detention costs and forced the company to take additional warehouses, contributing to the EBITDA decline alongside higher e-commerce spend and ₹6 crore in BCG consulting fees.
- The workout plan: Management intends to reduce inventory but not through deep discounting; instead, it will lean into the approaching backpack season, where a large portion of the inventory sits, and may delay new backpack launches to avoid compounding the problem.
- Soft luggage production halted: The company is not producing significant additional soft luggage at this point, consistent with the CapEx plan being put on hold.
CapEx Pivot: Hard Luggage In, Soft Luggage Out
- The original plan, shelved: A ₹200 crore CapEx plan for soft luggage capacity, including an additional plant each in India and Bangladesh, has been put on hold.
- The new priority: Hard luggage demand is higher than what the company can service; current capacity of 17 lac pieces is being expanded immediately to 20 lac pieces, requiring ₹50 crore in investment.
- FY24 spend: ₹25–30 crore already spent on hard luggage capacity; total CapEx for the year is expected around ₹80–85 crore.
- What went unaddressed: Management did not clarify the status of the original ₹200 crore plan or provide any FY25 CapEx outlook when asked directly.
Brand & Channel: Early Green Shoots in a Mixed Picture
- Aristocrat led the portfolio, outperforming all other brands this quarter.
- Skybag grew 12% after a long period of stagnation, signalling that new launches are beginning to gain traction.
- Caprese picked up on the back of new launches and activations; the base product work is done, and distribution is expanding through VIP stores, exclusive Carlton stores, and 50 planned exclusive Caprese kiosks of which 10 are already running. High growth is expected starting next year.
- E-commerce grew 50% as concentrated efforts with BCG and internal organization began to show results.
- Soft luggage growth resumed in Q2 after the Bangladesh disruption in Q1 was sorted.
- Store expansion on track: 63 stores opened in the first half, with around 40 more planned, taking the full-year addition to roughly 100 stores, of which 5–6 will be company-owned. Six airports have been signed for exclusive Carlton stores.
- Premiumisation push: Six luggage launches lined up between February and March across Skybag, VIP and Carlton, targeting lightweight, luxury and innovation segments, with a stated goal of a much better premium mix in the second half.
Radhika Piramal: "Bangladesh's ability to make the premium products or not what we expected and that has led to adverse brand mix that is not helping VIP given its overhead structure. It's important that we sell a certain number of premium or mid premium brands."
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue growth catch-up | Reach market growth rate | "In one or two quarters" |
| Product launches | 26 new launches | Next 3–4 months |
| Unusual freight/warehousing costs | Stabilize | "In one quarter or so" |
| H2 EBITDA improvement | ~500 bps improvement vs H1 | Second half of FY24 |
| Gross margin range | 53%–55% sustainable range | Going forward |
| Hard luggage capacity | Expand from 17 lac to 20 lac pieces | "Immediately" |
| FY24 CapEx | ₹80–85 crore total | FY24 |
| Store openings | ~40 more stores (100 total for FY24) | Balance of FY24 |
| Premium mix | "Much better" premium mix targeted | Second half |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q2 FY24 |
|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 6% YoY |
| Volume growth | 10% YoY |
| Gross margin | 55%, target achieved; better mix and full impact of crude reduction |
| EBITDA | ₹184 cr, vs ₹167 cr in Q1 FY24 |
| A&P spend | ₹56 cr, vs ₹30 cr in Q2 FY23 |
| Performance marketing spend (E-commerce) | ₹23 cr incremental, in other expenses |
| BCG consulting cost | ₹6 cr outflow in the quarter |
| Incremental freight and handling charges | ₹15 cr additional, including ₹5 cr on warehousing |
| E-commerce revenue growth | 50% YoY |
| E-commerce channel salience | 31% of revenue |
| Trade channel (GT, MT, Online) growth | 13% YoY |
| Skybag brand growth | 12% YoY |
| Premium brands salience | improved 2 percentage points vs Q1 FY24 |
| Industry growth estimate | 20% to 25% in Q2 |
| EBITDA guidance | improvement of 500 bps in H2 FY24 vs H1 FY24 |
| Gross margin guidance range | 53% to 55% going forward |
| EBOs opened in Q2 | 37, all through franchise route |
| New towns added | 57 in Q2 |
| Stores opened in H1 FY24 | 63; total additional stores planned for FY24: 100 (5-6 company-owned) |
| Airport stores signed | 6 airports for exclusive Carlton stores |
| Hard luggage capacity expansion CapEx | ₹50 cr planned; ₹25-30 cr already spent; FY24 total CapEx ₹80-85 cr |
| Current capacity | 17 lac pieces; immediately expanding to 20 lac |
| Soft luggage CapEx plan (₹200 cr) | put on hold |
| Performance marketing spend in Q1 FY24 | ₹12 cr |
| Caprese brand revenue | ~₹80 cr annually for last 4-5 years |
| Caprese kiosks planned | ~50 this year; 10 already operational |