Key Takeaways
- Strong volume-led quarter: Revenue grew 32% YoY on 25% volume growth, with all brands and channels contributing, while gross margin improved sequentially by ~1.3% and YoY by 0.5%.
- Supply chain transformation delivering: In-house manufacturing hit 73% of volumes, the highest ever, and capacity is up 65% since the pandemic with another ₹100 cr investment underway.
- Gross margin recovery is early-stage: Only one-third of raw material cost benefits flowed through in Q3, so the bulk of the tailwind is still to come, though mix shifts toward value categories will partly offset it.
- Channel rebalancing is working: Modern trade is recovering as Big Bazaar stores reopen, e-commerce is getting dedicated product ranges to reduce conflict, and general trade town penetration added 80 towns, reaching about 942 towns.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the reopened Big Bazaar stores deliver the expected bump, how much of the remaining raw material benefit converts to margin, and any early signs of unorganized sector resurgence as China reopens.
Demand & Volume Growth
- Broad-based volume expansion: 25% YoY volume growth was achieved on a completely remodeled supply chain, with hard luggage dominating but soft luggage and backpacks also performing well.
- Industry tailwind: Management expects the luggage industry to grow at a ~15% value CAGR over the next 3-5 years, with underlying volume growth somewhat lower, and is building supply chain capacity aggressively to capture that growth.
- Near-term demand: Demand appears good for the industry at least in the near future, though management declined to commit to a specific multi-year revenue target, calling the market too volatile for a safe prediction that far out.
- Unorganized sector watch: No early signs of the unorganized segment bouncing back as China reopens, but management is keeping a close watch given the potential competitive pressure on the value category.
Dutta: "I think the industry in terms of value terms should easily grow anywhere between 15% there about CAGR over the next 3 - 5 years underlying volume growth could be lesser, but I mean this could be the aggressive side of the growth that I would put, but expecting a 15% CAGR over the next 5 years, given the India's context should not be something that we could be shy of."
Gross Margin Trajectory
- Sequential improvement, early innings: Gross margin improved ~1.3% QoQ and 0.5% YoY, driven largely by raw material prices and ocean freight, but only one-third of the raw material cost benefit was realized in Q3 because the benefits started flowing only in the last month of the quarter.
- The offsetting headwind: Lower input costs are a tailwind, but the growing share of the value category (Aristocrat) and potential unorganized sector pressure will create some set-off, making the net margin outcome difficult to predict precisely.
- In-house manufacturing benefit: 73% of Q3 sales were manufactured in-house, but the margin benefit was partially offset by the higher share of Aristocrat (mix effect ~70%) and elevated ocean freight and inflation (~30%).
- Ambition vs commitment: Management's gross margin ambition is ~55%, with a nearer-term FY24 target of 52-53%, and a commitment to keep gross margin in the 50-53% range in the interim.
Dutta: "On one side, the tailwind is prices coming down on the other side the headwind is also the mix and the value category growing and the unorganized sector pushing the growth further so there will be some kind of set off happening and it's difficult to predict that part because the volatility is more there and margin is a result of that."
Channel Dynamics
Modern Trade
- Big Bazaar recovery underway: Approximately 235 of 279 Big Bazaar stores had reopened by December, and these are expected to help in the coming quarter, though management cautioned this will bring a bump rather than complete consumption growth as the catchment area reaches a new equilibrium.
- Share diversification: Future Group's contribution has dropped from 44% pre-COVID to ~20-22% now, with VIP consciously pushing to gain share in weaker accounts like Vishal Mega Mart and regional chains to compensate.
- Reliance Smart Bazaar reach has expanded from ~45 stores at the beginning of the year to 235 stores currently.
E-commerce
- Below potential, below fair share: E-commerce performed well but is not at full potential, and management acknowledged it does not have the same market share or leadership position in e-commerce that it holds in offline channels.
- Channel conflict management: VIP now has a separate set of products for e-commerce to reduce channel conflict, and the mix is slowly changing in favor of more common products across channels.
- Spending intensity to increase: Plans are in place to balance spends slightly more in favor of e-commerce going forward and increase the intensity of e-commerce investment.
- Seasonality note: Q2 is far bigger for e-commerce in the luggage industry, so Q3's lower share partly reflects sector seasonality rather than competitive loss.
Dutta: "I do not have fair share, whatever share I have in the other channels, I don't have that, and I definitely don't have leadership in e-commerce."
General Trade & EBOs
- Town penetration expanding: General trade increased town penetration by 80 towns to 942, with an ambition to be in every town with a population of 50,000 or more.
- EBO count rising: 443 exclusive brand outlets are operational, 42 are under fit-out, and the target is to cross 500 before 31st March 2023.
Brand & Category Updates
- Product launch momentum: Skybags launched a FIFA collection, VIP introduced Highlander rugged hard luggage, Carlton launched a premium soft luggage range, and Caprese launched a range by designer Manish Malhotra.
- Caprese repositioning: The brand is being repositioned to the mid-premium and above segment (₹2,000-₹4,000, sweet spot ₹2,500-₹3,000), with channel focus shifting to D2C in all forms including its own website launched ~4 weeks ago, plus pilots for exclusive experience stores.
- Backpack strategy: Management sees a large opportunity in the mid-segment for backpacks and is not looking to replicate the Alfa/Aristocrat low-price mass-market strategy in this category.
- Soft luggage picking up: While hard luggage continues to dominate, soft luggage is gaining traction as supplies improve.
Dutta: "I won't say we are shifting from A to B, we are just repositioning ourselves to what the brand started with, where there is a larger void where there's a play of great design and great brand and therefore there is a value creation happening."
Supply Chain & Manufacturing
- In-house manufacturing at peak: 73% of volumes came from own manufacturing, the highest ever, with capacities up 65% since the pandemic.
- Capacity investment: ₹100 cr is being invested in FY23, split roughly ₹50 cr in India and ₹50 cr in Bangladesh, adding almost 200,000 sq ft of manufacturing space since FY20.
- Bangladesh productivity: Manufacturing productivity in Bangladesh is already getting closer to China levels, and per-hour labor cost is significantly in favor of India first, then Bangladesh as the most favorable.
- Sourcing mix for FY24: Management expects ~60% in-house, 20-25% outsourced within India, and 10-15% from China including Caprese, though splits can alter based on commercial sense.
- Backward integration: Pilots for manufacturing trolleys and wheels have been done, and this will happen in the coming financial year, but management is currently more focused on supply chain scaling and will take it up in a big way after crossing peak demand in Q1.
International & Exports
- UAE deepening: VIP has achieved double-digit market share in chains like Carrefour and Lulu in the UAE, with international business growing deeper in high-potential markets.
- Export recovery: The export business is recovering and is on track to close FY23 at much more than the pre-COVID level of ~₹100 crore, though management is not aiming to take share of the global market, with focus remaining on large India.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| EBO count | Cross 500 exclusive brand outlets | By 31st March 2023 |
| Gross margin range | Maintain 50% to 53% | Ongoing commitment |
| Gross margin target | Achieve 52-53% | FY24 |
| EBITDA margin target | Achieve ~20% (if 52-53% gross margin achieved) | FY24 |
| Advertisement spend | Maintain at 5-6% of sales | Going forward |
| Effective tax rate | Continue in 18% to 20% range | Going forward |
| Backward integration | Begin manufacturing trolleys and wheels at scale | Coming financial year, after peak demand in Q1 |
| Insurance balance payment | Receive payment (in last stage) | Q4 FY23 |
| Future Group stock recovery clarity | Clarity expected | By end of next quarter |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue growth | 32% YoY, 22% over pre-COVID base |
| Volume growth | 25% YoY, ~18% over pre-COVID base |
| Gross margin | +1.3% QoQ sequential improvement, +0.5% YoY improvement |
| Gross margin target range | 50% to 53%, with a shift toward the higher end |
| Gross margin ambition | ~55% |
| FY24 gross margin target | 52% to 53% |
| FY24 EBITDA margin target | 20%, if 52-53% gross margin achieved |
| Advertisement cost | ₹29 cr, vs ₹9 cr in Q3 FY22 |
| Advertisement spend target | 5% to 6% of sales going forward |
| Effective tax rate FY23 | ~18% to 20%, due to dividend from Bangladesh |
| Own manufacturing share of volumes | 73%, highest ever ratio in any quarter |
| Own manufacturing capacity increase | 65% since pandemic |
| Manufacturing capex FY23 | ~₹100 cr (~₹50 cr India, ~₹50 cr Bangladesh) |
| Manufacturing space added since FY20 | ~200,000 sq ft |
| EBO count | 443 (160 company-owned, 283 franchisee), excludes 42 under fit-out |
| Town penetration | ~942 towns, added 80 towns in Q3 |
| E-commerce revenue contribution | 13% in Q3 FY23, vs 22% in Q2 FY23 |
| Future Group Big Bazaar stores reached | 235 of 279 stores open and reached |
| Future Group contribution to modern trade | ~20% to 22%, vs 44% pre-COVID |
| Future Group exposure balance | ~₹12 cr |
| Raw material duty advantage from Bangladesh | 15% advantage on raw material part (~50% of business) |
| Like-to-like gross margin benefit (Bangladesh vs China) | 3% to 4% |
| Raw material cost benefit realized in Q3 | ~1/3rd of total benefit; benefits started in last month of quarter |
| Current raw material price vs VIP's operating cost | ~4% to 5% lower weighted average price in market (management caveat) |
| Caprese sweet-spot price point | ₹2,500 to ₹3,000, range ₹2,000–₹4,000 |
| Exports pre-COVID | ~₹100 cr business; closing on much more than that in FY23 |
| Industry value CAGR expectation (next 3-5 years) | ~15% |
| Mix vs other factors in manufacturing benefit deterioration | 70% mix (higher Aristocrat share), 30% other factors (inflation, ocean freight), per management's intuitive judgment |