Key Takeaways
- A brutal quarter, with more pain ahead: Margins turned miniscule or negative at current specs, and management warned Q2 could be considerably lower than Q1. The company is running 8–10% of spindles idle and expects another three to four months of pain.
- The core problem is Indian cotton’s price disconnect: International cotton fell from ~USD1.40–1.50 to USD0.90, but Indian cotton only dropped from INR105,000 to INR80,000–82,000, leaving Indian spinners uncompetitive and unable to capture export demand.
- All unstarted expansion is now on hold: Management paused new CapEx until Indian cotton prices realign with international levels and basic profitability normalizes, a decision it will revisit in a couple of months.
- The pipeline is empty, setting up a potential snapback: With global inventories depleted, capacity down across the industry, and brands on a wait-and-watch, a sudden crush of orders is possible once cotton prices stabilize.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether Indian cotton prices converge toward international levels as the new crop arrives from October, whether the inventory revaluation hit lands in Q2 or Q3, and whether the paused expansion plans get a restart signal.
The Cotton Price Disconnect
- Indian cotton is stuck at an uncompetitive premium: International prices collapsed from ~USD1.40–1.50 to USD0.90, but Indian cotton only eased from INR105,000 to INR80,000–82,000. At INR82,000–83,000 (USD1.37–1.38), India cannot compete for export contracts.
- Three factors created this year’s chaos: The domestic crop was damaged (only ~2.95 crore bales), an import duty restriction blocked relief, and long shipment periods with very high freight prevented normal transit of foreign cotton. All three hit simultaneously.
- The market is frozen, not clearing: At current prices there is neither a buyer nor a seller; the quoted price is more theoretical because the underlying shortage is not easing.
- Relief is tied to the new crop: November/December futures at INR64,000–65,000 signal a sharp drop ahead. Management expects prices to align with the international market only from October or November onward, when new physical arrivals begin.
- The new crop looks promising: Rains have been adequate in all cotton areas, acreage is up 5–6%, and early industry estimates point to a crop of ~3.6 crore bales.
Neeraj Jain: "There is neither a buyer, nor a seller at these prices and it's more of a theoretical price because of the shortage is not coming down."
Margin Trajectory & Inventory Risk
- Margins are already miniscule or negative: At current specs, spinning margins are almost negative. Q2 margins could be considerably lower than Q1, though management declined to quantify because cotton is moving too fast.
- Q1 was protected by pre-peak cotton: Every factory had some cotton procured before prices peaked, and pending contracts were still executing at higher prices. The real squeeze only began from May/June/July onward.
- An inventory revaluation hit is coming: When new, cheaper cotton arrives, every spinning mill will take a double hit: expensive cotton held in inventory gets revalued downward, and finished goods valued at old cotton cost plus conversion get readjusted to new lower prices. This flows through the P&L indirectly via raw material cost, with no separate line item.
- The timing depends on buying: The hit lands in Q2 or Q3 depending on when new-crop cotton buying starts. Finished goods inventory normally runs 20–25 days, so the adjustment will not be instantaneous.
- Long-term margin band is 18–22%: Management reiterated this normalized range, with last year an exception on the positive side and this year likely an exception on the negative side.
Neeraj Jain: "We have always taken this, knew that the margins for the company would be in the range of about 18% to 22%. The good year could be 22%, or towards the higher band and the bad year could be towards the lower band. Of course, last year was an exception towards the positiveness. This year could be an exception towards the negative side."
Demand Environment
- Global demand has collapsed into wait-and-watch: Brands stopped buying as commodity prices fell; everyone globally (Vietnam, China, India) is sitting on empty order books. The difference is that Indian spinners selling are taking a loss, while competitors are not.
- The fabric inventory correction amplified the slowdown: Logistics easing meant goods stuck at ports reached brands faster than expected, causing sudden inventory buildup. Offices reopening also shifted demand from casual/work-from-home clothing to office wear, creating a demand-supply mismatch for brands.
- The pipeline is absolutely empty: Inventories are depleted across spinners, traders, and even CCI because India exported heavily when domestic prices were lower. Once customers see stable or bottoming prices, demand should restart.
- A sudden demand crush is possible: With overall capacity down 30–35% and pipelines empty, a rapid snapback of orders when demand returns is not impossible.
- Bangladesh demand is structurally positive: If Bangladesh continues taking share from China, overall demand for Indian yarn from Bangladesh will remain good.
Neeraj Jain: "There is all likelihood of this scenario which you are mentioning, that since the overall capacity is down, the pipelines are empty, suddenly once the demand comes in, there could be a possibility because of pipeline the certain demand can again give a big push to the overall system."
Capacity & Operational Response
- 8–10% of spindles are stopped: Management idled capacity where there are no regular or committed customers. For regular customers, the company is willing to take the hit and buy cotton at current prices to supply them.
- Fabric utilization is down 10–15%: The slowdown extends beyond spinning into fabric, though fabric prices have not fallen as sharply as yarn because of the usual time lag.
- The near-term strategy is survival: The company is actively shifting capacity to alternate products to at least cover fixed costs, retain customers, and sustain them through the difficult period.
- Customer commitment is non-negotiable: Management was explicit that for regular customers, there is no second thought: the company will supply irrespective of cost or price.
Neeraj Jain: "We are very clear for the customer. There's no second thought even I mean, there's not, we were very clear that customer wants something, irrespective of the cost or price, we will not leave them."
CapEx & Expansion
- All unstarted expansions are on hold: Projects yet to begin have been paused temporarily, driven both by the industry situation and high machinery costs with supply chains stretched 2–2.5 years out.
- The restart trigger is margin normalization, not cheaper machines: Management will revisit expansion only when raw material prices align with international levels and basic profitability normalizes. It expects to take a view in a couple of months.
- Ongoing projects continue: The 100,000-spindle expansion already underway will be implemented over the next 2–3 months, with one plant partially started and completion delayed to September/October due to chip and machinery unavailability.
- Fabric expansion is bottleneck-removal only: Surplus gray fabric capacity exists, so the focus is on balancing equipment rather than adding new lines. Further fabric expansion will be considered only when utilization consistently hits ~1.4 crore meters for a couple of months.
- Volume growth without new capacity: Even with no major capacity addition, ~5% volume CAGR is possible for the next 1–2 years, and 20% year-on-year volume is available just from raising average utilization to full capacity.
Neeraj Jain: "It's not that the prices of machine will come down, that's why we are delaying it. No, it's not like that. It's the basic profitability should be restored, or the margin should be normalized, then only we will take up these projects."
Structural Tailwinds (On Hold, Not Broken)
- China Plus One remains intact: Brands have not deviated from the strategy. Once costs normalize, India has the possibility to regain market share. Xinjiang concerns and customers’ desire for a second supply source reinforce the trend.
- India’s yarn export position is hard to displace: India controls 25–30% of the world’s yarn export market; no other country can immediately capture that demand.
- China is structurally exiting spinning: China’s spindle capacity has fallen from a peak of 11.2 crore spindles a decade ago to 9.4 crore now, and its cost structure does not support spinning.
- FTA benefits are accumulating: FTAs with Australia and the UAE are signed, the UK is expected by Diwali, and the EU is underway. These will give India duty-free export access and increase market share, particularly for final consumer products rather than yarn.
- PLI and integrated textile parks are longer-term catalysts: The PLI scheme for synthetics has attracted significant interest, and government mega parks for garmenting could raise domestic demand if successful. Vardhman will evaluate Mitra park schemes once announced, with no major investment decision expected in the next six to nine months.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| CapEx restart decision | Revisit paused expansion plans once raw material prices align with international levels and margins normalize | "A couple of months" |
| 100,000-spindle expansion completion | Entire new capacity implemented | October–November |
| Cotton price alignment | Indian cotton prices to converge with international market when new crop physical arrivals begin | October/November onward |
| Inventory revaluation hit | Loss on revaluation of expensive cotton and finished goods inventory flows through P&L | Q2 or Q3, depending on when new-crop buying starts |
| Fabric expansion trigger | Consider further fabric expansion only when utilization consistently hits ~1.4 crore meters | "For a couple of months" at that level |
| Integrated textile park evaluation | No major investment decision expected | Next six to nine months |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q1 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | ₹2,800 cr (includes duty drawback) |
| Operating margin | Negative or miniscule at current spot levels (management confirmed for current levels, not specifically "operating margin") |
| Forward contract provision | ₹41 cr loss booked in Q1 (analyst stated; management did not confirm the figure) |
| Spinning capacity utilization | ~91–92% (8–9% of capacity stopped) |
| Fabric capacity utilization | 80–85% |
| Yarn export volume (India) | 2.5–3 cr kg per month, down ~80% from normal 11 cr kg |
| Indian cotton price (spot) | ₹80,000–83,000/candy (USD1.37–1.38), down 25–30% from peak of ₹1,05,000–1,06,000 |
| International cotton price (NY future) | USD0.90–0.92, down from peak of USD1.55–1.56 in Jun/Jul |
| India cotton premium to NY future | ~USD0.45, vs normal USD0.05–0.07 |
| Indian cotton Nov/Dec futures | ₹64,000–65,000/candy (USD1.03–1.04), ₹17,000–18,000 below spot |
| Industry spinning capacity stopped (India) | 30–35% |
| Next season crop estimate | ~3.6 cr bales, with 5–6% area growth and good rains |
| Long-term normalized margin range | 18–22% (FY22 was positive exception; FY23 could be negative exception) |
| Announced spindle expansion | 2.5 lakh spindles announced + 1 lakh under implementation, reaching ~0.15 cr spindles in 3–4 years |
| Spread for margin breakeven | USD0.70–0.80 (management said "close to about USD0.80, I think we start becoming positive. USD0.70 to USD0.80, we start becoming positive") |