Key Takeaways
- Demand bottoming, not yet normalizing: Utilization has rebounded sharply from ~50% to 85–100% across segments, but margins remain compressed because global capacity utilization is still only ~70%.
- China’s return is the swing factor: After a 7–9 month absence, Chinese buying of Indian yarn restarted in late December, with January exports expected to be 1–1.5 crore kg higher than December’s 5.3–5.4 crore kg.
- Cotton price distortion persists: Indian cotton trades at an unusual premium to New York futures because farmers are holding stock on an unprecedented scale, and the 11% import duty blocks arbitrage.
- Inventory losses are still flowing through: Margins took a hit from devaluation of finished goods and WIP as cotton prices fell; some losses likely continued in Q3, and profitability normalization is not expected in Q4.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the China restocking sustains beyond the initial pent-up burst, whether farmer-held cotton finally reaches the market, and whether brand inventory destocking in the US and Europe concludes.
Demand Environment
- Utilization recovery underway: Cotton spinning utilization, which had fallen to ~50% at its worst, has recovered to 85–90% in the last three to four weeks. Vardhman itself is running at 100% capacity for the last 1.5–2 months, with the share of alternate products (poly/viscose) down from 12–13% to 2–4%.
- Three headwinds easing: The demand collapse was driven by a general slowdown from oil/gas prices and recession fears, brands sitting on high inventories and refusing to buy, and China’s COVID restrictions. All three are now showing signs of abating.
- Segment-by-segment picture: Home textiles improved from 45–50% utilization to 65–70%. Denim exports remain at ~50% but domestic demand lifted overall denim utilization from 50% to ~70%. Woven mills are at 80–85%. Knit improved from 50–55% to 60–70%. Improvement is visible in every segment, but all remain suboptimally utilized.
- Fabric demand still sluggish: Retail sales are slow across the US, Europe, Asia including India and Japan due to inflation concerns. Brands are still carrying higher-priced inventory from previous quarters and offering hefty discounts, which pressures their cash flows and buying appetite.
- India retail mixed: Last quarter was unexpectedly slower for domestic retail; this quarter is seeing better demand from the marriage season.
- Customer base static: Hardly any new customers were added in this period; most business was with existing customers.
Neeraj Jain: "it looks like only I can say for most of these segments probably the worst is over but I do not think anyone can make really good money till the time the entire value chain"
China & Export Dynamics
- China restocking began late December: Till December there was no improvement in yarn exports to China; buying started only in the second or third week of December. January figures are expected to be higher, possibly 1–1.5 crore kg above December’s 5.3–5.4 crore kg.
- Why China is buying: China is importing yarn from India for both domestic and export markets, but primarily for exports. The expectation is that pent-up demand will follow China’s reopening after COVID, though the next 1–2 months may still have difficulties as herd immunity builds.
- Pakistan displacement: Pakistan’s spinning sector is in very bad condition: its cotton crop failed, imported cotton was bought at very high cost, and exports to China have come down significantly. India is replacing Pakistan’s share. Pakistan’s next crop arrives only in July or August, so India should have an edge for the next two quarters or so.
- Pakistan benefit is broad: The advantage should extend beyond spinning to woven, denim, and home textiles, all segments where Pakistan competes.
- Chinese yarn imports into India reversed: The trend of Chinese cotton yarn coming into India, noted last quarter, is not happening now.
Cotton Market & Raw Material
- Unprecedented farmer holding: For the first time in Indian history, farmers are holding cotton on a large scale in expectation of better prices, as they received last year (Rs.9,000–10,000). Arrivals are short by 1.65 crore bales versus last year, not due to non-availability but because of pricing expectations. International prices have fallen from 140 US cents to 85 cents, but farmers are still holding.
- Price distortion from import duty: The 11% import duty on cotton means that when the domestic crop is short, all 3.3 crore bales of Indian cotton trade at a premium because mills cannot import to arbitrage the spread. Management wants this issue resolved before committing to any very large capacity expansion.
- Procurement stance cautious: At the current spread of Indian cotton versus New York futures, management has no intention of buying very big quantities. Cotton will be bought as required; good quality cotton is available in the country, and there is no pressure to stock six months by end of March.
- Inventory valuation mechanics: Cotton mark-to-market never happens; closing inventory is valued at cost. Inventory losses in the quarter occur on finished goods and WIP, not on raw material cotton. Cotton is valued on a weighted-average-cost basis, so average inventory cost remains higher than current market price when cotton prices are falling.
- Hedging constraints: No hedging positions are outstanding because cotton stocks are at a bare minimum. RBI does not permit hedging positions unless physical stock is available.
- Price correction underway: In management’s view, cotton prices should have come down by now; a correction has happened in the last one to one-and-a-half months to quite an extent and will take another couple of weeks.
Neeraj Jain: "This is the first time in the history of India where the farmer is holding in expectation of a better price it has never happened in the history of India till now."
Margins & Profitability
- Q3 margin compression: Margins are much lower compared to the immediate preceding quarter because of devaluation of stocks, very low utilization, no exports from India due to global demand pressures especially from Europe and USA, and very high cotton prices.
- Inventory losses still flowing: Partial losses were already booked last quarter when cotton prices were Rs.80,000–85,000; some losses are likely even in the current quarter. Management declined to quantify the Q3 inventory loss amount, suggesting analysts can calculate it from market cotton prices and stock levels.
- Fabric margins relatively better: Fabric margins are better than yarn currently because when yarn prices come down, fabric prices do not come down in the same proportion, as orders were booked at higher prices.
- Normalization not in Q4: Management does not expect profitability to normalize in Q4. The situation may improve from the earlier period, but margins will not normalize until worldwide capacity utilization improves beyond 70%. Currently the entire world is running at only ~70% capacity utilization.
- Guidance declined: Management declined to put any guidance on Q4 margins or a return to double-digit margins, calling it "too risky" and "not desirable at this stage" given that customers buy only for the next four weeks, cotton price uncertainty persists, and no mill has inventory beyond three to four weeks.
- Fabric EBITDA structurally stable: Management is not seeing any structural change in fabric EBITDA margin; they are trying to maintain the same EBITDA margin as before, though the competitive space is changing.
Neeraj Jain: "the kind of volatility we have seen in the last six months it is anybody's guess how the tomorrow will be."
Capacity, Capex & Policy
- 65,000-spindle expansion progressing: Commercial production has partially started; full production is expected by end of February.
- Large expansion on hold: Management is not in a hurry to place all orders today. They want to wait for the situation to normalize and for the import duty on cotton issue to be resolved before taking any very big expansion decision. Coming from a big setback, with utilization improving only in the last couple of weeks, they want to pause and see how the situation and government view evolves.
- FY2024 capex modest: Next year’s capex will be normal, maybe in the range of ₹200 crores or so, majorly maintenance.
- RoDTEP disadvantage on advance authorisation: When importing duty-free cotton under advance authorisation for export, the company loses RoDTEP and duty drawback, which is a significant disadvantage because conversion-cost duty refunds are not available. The company has gone back to the government with a suggestion to provide RoDTEP on advance authorisation; the government is working on it, but no decision timeline can be commented on.
- Australia FTA benefit: The Australia FTA has been signed, giving India a level playing field with a duty-free advantage of 5–8% on cotton garments that competitors like Bangladesh already had. Some exports have started happening from India to Australia.
Neeraj Jain: "I still feel before we take a very big expansion this issue must be resolved otherwise this issue will keep coming up time and again whenever the crop is short"
Fabric Business Mix
- Mix shift toward top-hand and yarn-dyed: Four to five years ago the fabric ratio was more skewed toward solid and bottom-weight. Capacity expansion was done more on the top-hand side and yarn-dyed side, so the mix is now quite balanced.
- Disclosure reluctance: When asked to share per-meter benchmark product prices or the detailed mix between bottom-weight, yarn-dyed, and value-added segments, management was initially reluctant to answer and provided only a range for the largest commodity item after being pressed.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| 65,000-spindle capacity addition | Full commercial production | End of February 2023 |
| Pakistan competitive advantage | India to have an edge over Pakistan across spinning, woven, denim, and home textiles | Next two quarters or so (until Pakistan’s July/August crop) |
| Cotton price correction | Correction has happened to quite an extent; will take another couple of weeks to complete | A few weeks from now |
| FY2024 capex | Normal capex, ~₹200 crores, majorly maintenance | FY2024 |
| Fabric EBITDA margin | Trying to maintain same EBITDA margin as before, depending on competitive/market situation | Next couple of years |
| Large capacity expansion decision | Paused until import duty on cotton issue is resolved and situation normalizes | No timeline; waiting for government view and market normalization |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q3 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated [1-24] |
| Operating margin | Not stated [1-24] |
| Net profit | Not stated [1-24] |
| Cotton-yarn spread | 60 cents to 65 cents currently |
| Average cotton-yarn spread for Q3 | Close to about 60 cents |
| Yarn price (common count) | About Rs.270 per kg |
| Indian cotton clean cost | Rs.220 to Rs.225 per kg, at December rate of Rs.63,000 per candy |
| Yarn price (international) | Close to about $3.30, down from almost $4.60–$4.70 |
| Fabric commodity item average price | 95 to 97 last quarter, currently 77 to 79, about 20% lower than Q3 |
| Capacity utilization (Vardhman) | 100% for the last about one-and-a-half to two months |
| Capacity utilization (Indian cotton spinning) | 85% to 90% currently, improved from a low of 50% |
| Capacity utilization (worldwide spinning) | Not more than 75% currently |
| Yarn sold externally | 65% of production; internal consumption 35% to 37% |
| Cotton inventory (mills sector) | Not more than one month currently |
| Cotton inventory (Vardhman) | Not more than a month |
| India yarn exports (December) | 5.3 crore to 5.4 crore kg, up from a low of 3.5 crore kg in September/October |
| China share of India's yarn exports | 20% to 25% |
| Spindle capacity (post-expansion) | 11.91 lakh spindles by end of March |
| Gross consolidated debt | ₹1,500 crores |
| Cash and investments | Close to ₹2,400 crores |
| FY2023 capex | ₹600 to ₹650 crores, majorly on spinning side |
| FY2024 capex | About ₹200 crores, normal/maintenance capex |
| Fabric business mix (value-added) | About 25% high value-added; 65% value-added total (40% low, 25% high) |
| Fabric business mix (top-to-bottom) | 50-55% bottom, 45% top |
| Alternate product capacity shift | 12% to 13% of capacity converted earlier, now down to 2% to 4% |
| Brands resuming orders | 70% to 80% of brands have started ordering in small quantities |
| Pakistan cotton crop loss | Down to about 50% of consumption |
| India cotton imports | 10 lakh to 15 lakh bales annually |
| Cotton import duty-free period | Until October 31, 2022 |
| Australian FTA duty advantage | 5% to 8% on cotton garments |
| Indian cotton premium to NY Future (current) | Plus 10 cents, down from as high as 35 to 40 cents |
| Normal margin range (raw material premium) | 3 to 4 US cents above NY Future |