Key Takeaways
- Extraordinary margin squeeze, not a demand collapse: Current cotton and yarn prices would yield negative or miniscule EBITDA if business were done at those levels, but the company is running at 85–90% utilization and expects demand to bounce back.
- Cotton prices are the entire story: A speculative rally, poor Indian crop quality, and import duty friction have pushed domestic cotton well above international parity, leaving Indian spinners in more pain than global peers.
- Fabric provides a partial shield: Fabric demand was rebounding after six weak quarters and margins are stickier when raw material eventually falls, but the whole chain is under pressure from brand resistance to price increases.
- Expansion on ice, liquidity preserved: The next phase of spindle capacity is on hold for 3–6 months, no new hedging contracts are being entered, and management emphasizes comfortable liquidity as a competitive advantage when conditions normalize.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the expected Q2 utilization bounce to 95–100% materializes, the pace of cotton price adjustment as the new crop outlook firms, and the quantum of the remaining Q1 mark-to-market hedging loss.
The Cotton Shock
- Price surge driven by speculation, not fundamentals: Management sees no demand-side reason for cotton to double year-on-year; easy-money speculative positions across commodities are the primary driver.
- Domestic premium over global: Indian cotton prices are higher than imported cotton including Australian, because of a downward revision to Indian crop estimates and an import duty that makes foreign cotton costlier.
- Quality compounds the cost problem: Indian cotton quality is very poor this year, so realized yields are lower, making the effective cost even higher than quoted prices suggest.
- Inventory thin across the system: Spinners are carrying only 2–3 months of inventory against a normal 6–8 months because raw material was simply not available in the system earlier, so nobody could buy large quantities.
- Duty-free window too late to help: The government relaxed import duty until 30th September, but by the time relief was granted hardly any crop was available outside, and the shipment window from Brazil and Australia leaves importers exposed to 11% duty if cotton lands after the deadline.
- New crop is the only real fix: World cotton crop could increase 8–10%, India’s area could rise 15–18%, and with yield improvement the Indian crop could grow roughly 20%. Supply stays tight until new crop arrives in volume from November.
Neeraj Jain: “I think it is more than physical demand, there are lots of demand who have taken a position because of easy money policy. So, they have invested into various commodities including cotton. So, that is one of the reasons the prices have been going up otherwise on fundamental we not feel or find any reason why the cotton should be double compared to the last year when there is not kind of demand increase happening in the raw cotton prices.”
Margin Mechanics
- Spinning margins at crisis levels: The spinner markup over raw material cost, normally $1 to 20–30 cents, is now in the range of 80–90 cents, and on basic commodity products margins could be negative.
- Blended products losing less: Losses on cotton-poly and cotton-viscose blends are lower than on 100% cotton because synthetic fiber costs are much lower than cotton, and the company is shifting internal capacity accordingly.
- Fabric margins compressed but stickier: Fabric margins have come down to normal levels but are under pressure because yarn prices keep rising and end buyers resist. Historically, when yarn prices fall, fabric prices do not fall correspondingly, so fabric margins tend to be stickier on the way down.
- The pass-through is improving: Once yarn prices stabilize, management expects the 70–80% pass-through of yarn cost increases into fabric pricing to rise to 90% and eventually 100%, maybe in another month or so.
- Hedging loss added to the pain: A ₹60 crore mark-to-market loss hit Q4 because management hedged by selling New York futures when prices looked too high, and the market moved the opposite way. Q1 FY23 will carry a further but smaller mark-to-market loss on carried-forward contracts.
- Normalization needs one of two things: Either raw material prices must come down or yarn must start getting acceptance at higher levels; management cannot say whether that takes two, three, four, or six months.
Neeraj Jain: “Negative or miniscule I will say.”
Demand & Utilization
- Demand fundamentals intact, price resistance temporary: The China-plus-one factor remains in place and buyers still want India to deliver yarn, fabric, and garments, but resistance has emerged because prices crossed a threshold.
- Three headwinds beyond cotton: High cotton, yarn, and garment prices are reducing demand; fuel price increases from the Russia-Ukraine war are affecting overall consumption; and improving supply chains mean buyers may order less to readjust extra inventory over the next six months.
- Utilization dipped but not collapsed: The company ran at 100% through Q4 and expects 100% in Q1, but in the last 3–4 weeks utilization slipped to about 85–90%. Management expects it to start improving in another two weeks and sees Q2 rebounding to 95–100%, with first-half utilization averaging about 90–95%.
- Industry-wide cotton consumption down: Management estimates at least a 25% drop in cotton consumption versus earlier, driven mainly by reduced capacity utilization and partially, 5–10%, by substitution to viscose and polyester.
- Yarn prices capped by Vietnam: Yarn prices are being decided by Vietnam, the largest exporter, based on the blended cost of imported cotton. Since Indian cotton prices are higher, Indian spinners are in a more distressed situation and yarn prices are not expected to increase from current levels.
Neeraj Jain: “The momentum of the demand from India still continues to be good. The China plus one factor... they still want the India to deliver them to both yarn, fabric and the garment whatever we can do. So, I think on fundamentals I do not think there is any change happened in last three to four months’ time, but since our prices have increased over a point so that is where their resistance is coming to buy at these levels.”
Capacity, Capex & Competitive Dynamics
- Expansion on hold: The remaining spindle capacity additions beyond the first 100,000 spindles due in October 2022 have not been started. Management has applied for government approvals and incentives in Madhya Pradesh but will take a view after six months or so, committing no new expenditure now.
- Two projects nearing completion: The Budhni project and the Gore-Tex project at Satlapur are on schedule and likely to be completed by September or October this year, with only small delays from construction or machinery supply.
- Industry-wide capex freeze: No huge capacity addition is likely in the next 12–15 months because everyone wants to wait. Projects already started will be completed, but new commitments are paused. If margins and the China-plus-one trend stay good, capacity could eventually be added in Vietnam, India, Bangladesh, and Indonesia.
- Crisis as a catalyst for change: Management is working daily on what changes are required to operate better even at these prices, noting that crisis times give an opportunity to make changes that are difficult in normal times.
- Liquidity as a competitive weapon: The company is sitting very comfortably in terms of liquidity and cash availability, with no compromise on that front, which management believes will give an advantage when conditions normalize.
Neeraj Jain: “I think considering the situation as of now everyone wants to wait... I do not think next 12 months to 15 months there is any huge capacity addition likely to happen into the system, but yes, if the margins continues to be good or if the business continuous to be good and brands keep on moving at China Plus One, there could be capacity which could be added into Vietnam, India, Bangladesh maybe Indonesia, etc., because China in any case will be coming down.”
Product Mix & Strategic Shifts
- Shift from 100% cotton to blends underway: Some change has already started from 100% cotton to cotton-poly and cotton-viscose, driven by high cotton prices. Brands are looking to move to blends to reduce cost, and Vardhman is converting internal capacities to those products.
- Capacity is fungible: The company can easily shift capacity based on margin comparison across 100% cotton, cotton-poly, and cotton-viscose. In normal times, all three yield comparable margins; the current distortion is temporary.
- Fabric division recovering volume: Fabric demand was coming back after a lull of about six quarters as markets, schools, and offices reopened. Volume in the fabric division was increasing and consistent through Q4.
- Structural advantage survives the cycle: The Western world’s China-plus-one thought process continues, and the medium-term structural advantage for Indian spinners remains intact whenever the situation normalizes.
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Capacity utilization recovery | Q2 rebounding to 95–100%, first-half average about 90–95% | Q2 FY23 |
| Fabric price pass-through | 70–80% pass-through rising to 90% and eventually 100% of yarn price increases absorbed in fabric pricing once yarn prices stabilize | "Maybe in another month or so" |
| New capacity expansion decision | View taken after 6 months or so; no new expenditure committed now | After ~6 months |
| Budhni and Satlapur projects | Likely completed, with some small delay | September/October 2022 |
| Hedging policy | No new hedging contracts being entered; only carrying forward existing ones | Ongoing |
| Margin normalization | Either raw material comes down or yarn gets acceptance at higher levels, then margins should normalize | Uncertain: "whether it happens in two months or three months or four months or six months" |
| Full-year outlook | The year as a whole will still be better than the situation today | FY23 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY22 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not stated |
| Operating margin | Not stated |
| Net profit | Not stated |
| Hedging mark-to-market loss | ₹60 cr, provided on 31st March |
| Gross debt | Close to ₹2,000 cr as of March 22 |
| Net debt | ~₹500 cr, with investments of ~₹1,500 cr on book |
| Yarn capacity utilization | 100% in Q4; last 3–4 weeks at 85–90% |
| Yarn export share | ~35–40% of total production |
| Fabric price absorption of yarn increase | 70–80% of yarn price increase absorbed in last 5–6 months |
| Blended fiber capacity share | 20–25% of capacity on blends |
| Indian cotton consumption share | 92–93% Indian cotton, 7–8% imported |
| Cotton inventory value | ~₹2,900 cr as of March 31 vs ~₹2,800 cr last year |
| Domestic cotton price | Close to ₹100,000 per candy, vs ~₹46,000–47,000 last year |
| International cotton price | ~145 cents per pound, vs 70–75 cents last year |
| Indian cotton crop estimate | 3.15–3.24 cr bales, revised down from 3.5–3.6 cr bales |