Key Takeaways
- Utilization snapped back, margins did not: Spinning utilization rebounded from 60–65% to over 90% QoQ as destocking ended and cotton prices corrected, but fabric stayed at 80–85% and the Indian cotton premium over global prices kept margins under pressure.
- The Indian cotton premium is the core structural drag: Indian cotton traded at a 10–15% premium to international, partly locked in by an 11% import duty, and management warned that if this persists, expected margins may not return for two to three years even if global demand improves.
- Demand is healing slowly, not surging: Home textile utilization hit 90–95% in the final weeks, denim climbed from 40–45% to ~65%, and China resumed yarn buying after a six-month pause, but management called the next three to five months a "roller coaster" with no major trend in either direction.
- Expansion is on ice until cotton economics normalize: Management will not greenlight the announced 300,000-spindle project or any large CAPEX until Indian cotton prices align with world markets, and it wants to wait one to two years before even relooking at projects.
- What to watch next quarter: Whether the home textile green shoot sustains and pulls fabric utilization toward 100%, any movement in the cotton import duty that could narrow the premium, and whether the "roller coaster" tilts upward or down.
The Cotton Price Disadvantage
- Premium over global benchmarks: Indian cotton, comparable to American in length and strength but carrying contamination from manual picking, historically traded at a $0.04–$0.06 premium to New York futures. That premium widened to $0.12–$0.15, and Indian cotton is now at par with American cotton, erasing the discount that once offset the quality gap.
- Import duty locks the premium in: An 11% customs duty on cotton imports, introduced in the 2021 budget, prevents Indian mills from arbitraging cheaper global cotton. Farmers hold cotton domestically because the duty protects them, keeping local prices elevated.
- Yarn pricing suffers a double hit: Customers buy Indian yarn for darker-color products where contamination is acceptable, so they benchmark pricing against contamination-free yarn and will not pay a premium. Management estimates Indian yarn sells at roughly $0.20 lower than competitors' yarn, compressing the gross margin that the industry needs to earn a return.
- The structural yield problem behind it: India's cotton farms are extremely fragmented (0.6 crore farmers producing 3.4 crore bales, averaging 5 bales per farmer), rely on old seeds with no new seed approvals, and depend heavily on rain-fed acreage vulnerable to damage. A government committee under Mr. Suresh Kotak is working on seed replacement, but once a new seed is approved, experimentation and commercialization will take roughly three years.
Jain: "If our cotton price continues to be higher than the world markets, probably than the concern could be a little longer, even if the things improves worldwide… whether the kind of margins which are expected whether they would be back or not, in next two to three years."
Demand Recovery: Green Shoots, Not a Trend
- Spinning utilization led the rebound: Country-level spinning utilization collapsed to 60–65% in Q3 as brands destocked and cotton prices spiked to ₹100,000. Q4 saw a sharp recovery to over 90%, driven by the cotton price correction to ₹62,000–₹64,000, the end of brand destocking, and a resumption of Chinese yarn buying after a six-month COVID-driven pause.
- Fabric demand lagged: Fabric utilization stayed at 80–85% because overall textile demand remained under concern and brands were still working through inventory. Management is making efforts to increase fabric utilization but has not yet seen the same snapback.
- Home textile turned first: Capacity utilization in home textiles improved to 90–95% in the last couple of weeks of the quarter, signaling that destocking may be over and demand is returning. Management views this as the clearest green shoot and hopes other segments follow "in the near future over a period of time."
- Denim and knitting climbing from a low base: Denim utilization was 40–45% four months before the call and reached ~65% by quarter-end; knitting reached ~65–70%. Every segment has improved from its worst, but none is yet at the desired 100% level.
- Customer order horizons remain short: No customer is willing to place orders beyond 30–40 days, versus a normal pattern of 6–8 months, reflecting persistent caution across the value chain.
- Three macro headwinds easing, slowly: High inflation, interest rates, EMIs and energy prices reduced discretionary demand but are showing improvement; brand destocking has ended and buying has resumed; supply-chain concerns over goods devaluation have abated. US interest rates appear to have peaked and European energy prices are off their highs.
Jain: "next 3 to 5 months could be again a rollercoaster where all our efforts are to utilize the full capacity and keep serving the customer"
Margin Mechanics: Integrated, but Squeezed
- Integration provides a partial hedge: When yarn prices fall, fabric margins improve because yarn is the raw material for fabric. As an integrated player, Vardhman's overall EBITDA margins held up better than those of standalone spinners during the quarter. The reverse dynamic also holds: when yarn prices rise, fabric margins compress.
- The gross margin math does not work at current levels: Management stated that at a gross margin of $0.60–$0.70 per unit, the industry cannot make money. A return to viable economics requires roughly $0.90 to $1.00 of gross margin, a level not achievable while Indian cotton carries a premium and yarn sells at a discount.
- Blended vs. cotton yarn margins equalize: Margins are comparable between blended and cotton yarn because the same spindles can produce either. If one segment shows better margins, capacity shifts and the differential closes, so there is no structural margin advantage to chase.
- Other expenses benefited from a one-off comparison: Q4 FY22 included an extraordinary hedging loss on cotton derivatives, making the YoY decline in other expenses partly mechanical rather than operational.
- No hedging in the current environment: The company is not doing any hedging presently; it only hedges when importing in bigger ways, which is not happening this year.
CAPEX & Expansion: Frozen Until Cotton Normalizes
- The 300,000-spindle project is announced but paused: Management has a plan to add 300,000 spindles and could implement it in one go once the business model normalizes, but it will not proceed until raw cotton prices align with world markets. A spinning project can be completed in roughly 12 months once ordered, with machinery available in 6–8 months.
- No comfort on cost factors: Management is "not really, really comfortable going by the overall cost factors in the system" and wants to wait one to two years before relooking at projects. Expansion could happen in FY25 or so if not in FY24.
- The viability test is binary: If Indian cotton prices remain higher than world markets, management will not expand in a big way because that would raise "a basic question mark on the viability of the business." If the cotton disadvantage resolves and margins return, the company has the cash and appetite for an aggressive CAPEX plan.
- Spindle costs are rising structurally: Building material costs have risen substantially, and vendors now include automation features such as roving transportation and auto doffing as standard, pushing up the per-spindle cost of any future expansion.
- Global capacity is shifting, not growing uniformly: Uzbekistan, Bangladesh and Turkey are the bigger players adding spinning capacity; China is reducing; Pakistan and Indonesia are not adding; some capacity is coming in the Central American zone. No new groups have entered Indian spinning in a big way; expansions are scattered among existing players.
Jain: "we want to have the comfort before we relook at these projects. And as of now we are not really, really comfortable going by the overall cost factors in the system."
Balance Sheet & Capital Allocation
- Cash is high by design, not neglect: Cash represents roughly one-third of net worth and depresses reported earnings, but management prefers to wait for a better business scenario before investing. The cash position is elevated partly because the company did not buy enough cotton, not because of a structural surplus.
- Debt is mostly long-term and low-cost: Debt consists of debentures and term loans, some carrying government subsidies. There is no working-capital debt; export packing credit is available at much lower rates. Term loans carry lower interest, while debentures are at market price.
- Buyback was raised and deflected: An analyst asked whether a share buyback, last done in 2016/2017, could improve the balance sheet. Management responded that it was not the right person to answer and would convey the suggestion to the Board.
- PLI and technical textiles are not on the radar: Vardhman has not applied under the Textile PLI scheme, which is designed for 100% synthetic products, and the company has no plan for a 100% synthetic fabric base business. It is also not in technical textiles and is not thinking on those lines.
Operational Priorities & Modernization
- First priority is running full capacities: Management's immediate focus is finding customers, delivering the right products on time with variety, and keeping all segments at maximum utilization. Margin improvement can happen only after full capacity utilization is achieved across the board.
- Customer retention is non-negotiable: Even in a weak demand environment, the company cannot afford to lose customers and must ensure long-term advantages are not compromised.
- Modernization continues regardless of the cycle: The modernization process is ongoing even in the worst of times, and management is not compromising on that base. Internal efficiency improvement ideas are also being worked on.
- Farmer-level intervention is not feasible: An analyst asked whether the company could procure seeds from farmers and get output in return. Management declined, noting that annual consumption of 15 lakh bales would require working with roughly 300,000 farmers, which is "not our cup of tea."
Jain: "If my yarn is sold in $0.20 cents lower than them, how will I make money?"
Guidance & Commitments
| Commitment | Specifics | Timeline |
|---|---|---|
| Expansion decision | Will not expand in a big way unless Indian cotton prices align with world markets; wants 1–2 years of comfort before relooking at projects | FY25 or later |
| Spindle project implementation | Announced 300,000 spindles may be implemented in one go once business model normalizes; machinery available in 6–8 months, project completion in ~12 months from order | Conditional on cotton normalization |
| Margin recovery | Expected margins may not return if Indian cotton premium persists; gross margin needs to reach $0.90–$1.00 for viable returns vs. current $0.60–$0.70 | Possibly not in next 2–3 years if premium stays |
| Cotton price readjustment | Current higher/lower cotton prices are temporary; readjustment may happen | 6 months or so |
| New seed commercialization | Once government approves new seed, experimentation and commercialization will take ~3 years | ~3 years from approval (date unknown) |
| Near-term demand | Next 3–5 months could be a rollercoaster; no major trend expected in one direction | H1 FY24 |
Key Metrics
| Metric | Q4 FY23 |
|---|---|
| Revenue | Not disclosed (company does not share yarn/fabric split) |
| Spinning utilization | Almost full for Vardhman, improved from Q3 which was one of the worst quarters |
| Fabric utilization | 80% to 85%, still not reaching 100% |
| Spinning gross margin | $0.70 cents (market yarn price vs cotton), sometimes as low as $0.60 cents |
| Industry spinning gross margin | $2.60 to $2.70 cents (per an analyst's math) |
| EBITDA per kg (yarn) | ₹15 to ₹20 in best-case scenario, many places marginal or much less |
| 30s combed yarn realization | $3.30, down from $4.50 last year |
| Cotton price (Indian) | ₹62,000 to ₹64,000 a candy, down from as high as ₹100,000 in Q3 |
| Cotton price (international) | $78 to $85 cents per pound, average around $82 to $84 cents |
| Indian cotton premium over NY futures | $0.12 to $0.15 cents, historically $0.04 to $0.06 cents |
| Cotton inventory | ~60 days as of March 31, normally 7 to 8 months; valued at ~₹2,400 crore |
| Consolidated debt | ~₹1,800 crore |
| Cash and equivalents | ~₹2,700 crore, representing 33% of net worth |
| Maintenance CAPEX guidance (FY24) | ~₹300 crore |
| Home textile utilization (industry) | 90% to 95%, improved in last couple of weeks |
| Denim utilization (industry) | ~60%, improved from 40% to 45% four months back |
| Knitting utilization (industry) | ~65% to 70% |
| India spinning utilization (industry) | Higher than 90%, up from 60% to 65% in Q3 |
| Indian spinning capacity addition (net) | ~1.2 to 1.3 crore spindles in last one year, about 2% to 2.5% of installed capacity |
| Global spinning capacity addition (net) | ~0.4 crore spindles |
| Cost of new spinning capacity | ~₹80,000 per spindle, up from ₹50,000 to ₹55,000 five years back |
| Cotton arrival in India | ~2.35 to 2.4 crore bales; daily arrival 125,000 to 140,000 bales |